VKOSPI Surpasses Levels from the 2008 Financial Crisis
Extreme Concentration in Samsung Electronics and SK hynix Drives 78% of KOSPI's Gains
Now Is the Time to Diversify into Undervalued Earnings Plays

While the KOSPI 200 Volatility Index (VKOSPI), often referred to as the "Korean Fear Index," has soared to a historic high, the U.S. Fear and Greed Index remains relatively stable. Traditionally, during periods of heightened geopolitical risk or inflation shocks, both indices tend to move in the same direction. However, experts cite the recent "decoupling" between Korean and U.S. fear indices, attributing it to extreme concentration in semiconductor stocks.


Why Has Korea's 'Fear Index' Hit a Record High While the U.S. Remains Stable? View original image

According to the Korea Exchange on July 21, the VKOSPI closed at 86.87 on the previous trading day, down 0.31%. On June 29, it reached 96.94, the highest level since the exchange began officially announcing the index on April 13, 2009. This surpasses the closing record of 89.30 (unofficial) during the 2008 financial crisis on October 29, 2008. The VKOSPI represents the annualized 30-day expected volatility reflected in KOSPI 200 option prices. A reading in the 20s is considered average, above 30 indicates a period of heightened volatility, and above 40 is categorized as an extreme fear zone.


Typically, the VKOSPI rises when the KOSPI plummets, but recently, this benchmark has also been rising even during upturns in the market—a rare phenomenon. This is seen as a reflection of investor anxiety stemming from short-term overheating. The fear of missing out (FOMO) has sparked short-term buying, while heavy capital inflows into leveraged semiconductor single-stock exchange-traded funds (ETFs) launched at the end of May have created a "short gamma" cycle, where price swings prompt more selling during market fluctuations.


In contrast, the U.S. Fear and Greed Index, which quantifies market sentiment on a 0–100 scale, rose to 71 ("greed") in May but has since stayed within the 25 ("fear") to 47 ("neutral") range, even as tech stocks recently corrected. The index aggregates seven indicators: market momentum, stock price strength and breadth, options (put and call) demand, junk bond demand, volatility (VIX), demand for safe assets, and market breadth. A score of 0–24 indicates extreme fear, 25–44 is fear, 45–54 is neutral, 55–74 is greed, and 75–100 is extreme greed.


When geopolitical risk rocked markets in early March—amid intensifying concerns of war between the U.S. and Iran—the VKOSPI surged to 80.37 as the Fear and Greed Index plunged to 6, showing both measures moving together. The situation is now different, however, due to contrasting index compositions. In the U.S. S&P 500, semiconductor companies account for only about 18%, so when semiconductor shares undergo corrections, other sectors absorb the volatility. On the other hand, the KOSPI is highly concentrated, with Samsung Electronics and SK hynix making up over 50% of its market capitalization. As a result, turbulence in a small number of stocks immediately amplifies the volatility of the entire market.


Why Has Korea's 'Fear Index' Hit a Record High While the U.S. Remains Stable? View original image

Eugene Investment & Securities analyzed that the recent correction is not due to a deterioration in company fundamentals, but rather stems from excessive capital flows into a few semiconductor stocks, triggering supply-demand volatility. In fact, during the first half’s sharp rally, Samsung Electronics and SK hynix accounted for 78.3% of the KOSPI’s gains. This figure vastly outpaces the contributions from leading stocks in overseas markets, such as TSMC in Taiwan (38.9%), Japan’s Kioxia and SoftBank (36.8%), and the U.S. "Magnificent 7" (13.4%). Consequently, the daily volatility (standard deviation) of the U.S., Taiwanese, and Japanese markets—where fundamentals are broadly dispersed—remained stable at 1–2%, while volatility in the Korean market has soared to more than double that level.


Nevertheless, the recent correction has improved the valuation appeal of the Korean stock market. The KOSPI’s 12-month forward price-to-earnings ratio (PER) has dropped to between 6 and 7 times, hitting its lowest levels since the global financial crisis of 2008. The PER for non-semiconductor KOSPI sectors has also retreated to 8.6 times, approaching historic lows.


Experts stress that since corporate earnings forecasts remain solid, now is the time to manage risk by diversifying asset allocation rather than indiscriminately dumping shares. Eugene Investment & Securities researcher Hur Jae-hwan said, "The Korean stock market is likely to enter a period of consolidation over the near term, with further declines gradually abating. As the correction in semiconductor shares tempers the marginalization of other sectors, it is a good opportunity to broaden exposure to sectors such as machinery, shipbuilding, and cyclical stocks—areas whose valuations have become increasingly attractive."



Why Has Korea's 'Fear Index' Hit a Record High While the U.S. Remains Stable? View original image

Na Jeonghwan, a researcher at NH Investment & Securities, commented, "As volatility escalates, investors are pushed toward short-term responses and are rattled by worries about market peaks. However, share prices ultimately follow fundamentals. While there are signs of a market peak, the conditions that would end this bull run—namely, an earning momentum slowdown and a tightening of liquidity—have not yet emerged." He added, "Until those signals appear, the answer lies in sectors with high earnings visibility, including AI infrastructure, undervalued performance stocks, and premium consumption."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing