Lee Sang-eun, Attorney at Kyobo Life Insurance Comprehensive Asset Management and Financial Business Team

Lee Sang-eun, Attorney at Kyobo Life Comprehensive Asset Management & Financial Business Team. Kyobo Life

Lee Sang-eun, Attorney at Kyobo Life Comprehensive Asset Management & Financial Business Team. Kyobo Life

View original image

When a policyholder designates the insured's heirs as the beneficiaries of an insurance contract, the Supreme Court has consistently ruled that the right to claim the insurance proceeds is considered the heirs’ personal property, not part of the inheritance. This is because the right to claim insurance proceeds arises automatically from the validity of the insurance contract by the beneficiaries' status, and is not property inherited from the decedent.


This legal principle applies equally in cases where, for example, an insurance accident occurs before the life insurance policyholder exercises the right to designate a beneficiary, so that heirs become beneficiaries according to the relevant provisions of commercial law, even if a beneficiary was not designated.


Recently, the courts have also held that insurance proceeds received from certain insurance products—such as single-premium immediate annuity contracts with inheritance pension features, where the policyholder pays the premium in a lump sum, and the beneficiary receives monthly survival annuity payments and, upon maturity, a payout equal to the original premium, or, if the insured dies before maturity, a death benefit equal to the sum of the matured reserve and a certain additional amount—are still considered the personal property of the heirs.


However, if the policyholder designates themselves both as the insured and the beneficiary, makes the premium payments, and then dies, an exception is made: The proceeds are considered inheritance property. In addition, for tax purposes, life insurance payouts resulting from the decedent’s death, received under insurance contracts where the decedent is the policyholder, are considered inheritance property and are thus subject to inheritance tax.


In summary, whether insurance proceeds are treated as inheritance property or as the heir’s personal property determines several issues: whether receiving the life insurance payout constitutes disposal of estate property, thereby resulting in statutory simple acceptance by law, or whether an heir who has renounced or limited acceptance of the inheritance can nevertheless receive the life insurance payout.


What, then, if the heir receives the deceased's life insurance payout? The Supreme Court has held that, because death benefits received by the beneficiary heir are not inheritance property but the heir’s personal property, the act of receiving them does not constitute a “disposal of estate property” and therefore does not trigger statutory simple acceptance.


The rationale is that the basis for the heir receiving the insurance payout is not inheriting property from the decedent, but rather a “right” that the heir acquires directly against the insurance company as a party to the contract from the outset. The heir, therefore, claims the insurance proceeds not in the capacity of “heir,” but as “beneficiary,” meaning payments received on this legal basis are not considered inheritance property.


There are many cases in which creditors of the decedent file lawsuits against the heir, claiming that the heir has disposed of estate property and, therefore, by the effect of statutory simple acceptance, has inherited the estate—including the deceased’s debts—and thus has an obligation to repay them to the creditors. Sometimes, creditors argue that the heir’s receipt of insurance proceeds constitutes “disposal of inheritance property,” or that the insurance company’s deduction of outstanding policy loans under the terms and conditions before paying out the balance also constitutes disposal of inheritance property. However, the courts have ruled that insurance proceeds paid based on the insurance contract are not part of the estate, and that set-off of policy loans is not a proactive repayment of debts by the heir, but rather a standard procedure carried out according to the terms of the insurance contract; hence, it cannot be regarded as disposal of inheritance property.


According to the above legal principles and precedents, receiving life insurance proceeds is considered the heir’s personal property and not disposal of inheritance property. Therefore, even if the heir later files for limited acceptance or renunciation of inheritance, whether the insurance payout constitutes disposal of estate property does not become an issue.


However, if the funds paid by the insurance company include not only death benefits but other payments such as diagnosis fees, actual medical expenses, or surrender values—which may count as inheritance property—these sums may be regarded as inheritance property received from the decedent and thus subject to inheritance procedures. Accepting and using such payments could be considered disposal of estate property and may result in statutory simple acceptance by law.


On the other hand, it is generally not regarded as “disposal of inheritance property” if the heir withdraws deposits or insurance payouts from the estate but uses them specifically to cover the funeral expenses of the decedent. This principle applies only when such expenditures fall within a reasonable range given the decedent’s social status or customs, and in these cases statutory simple acceptance does not apply.


In conclusion, even if the decedent has significant debts and the heirs are considering renunciation or limited acceptance of inheritance, the life insurance payout received by the heir as beneficiary is their personal property and may lawfully be used for living expenses or other purposes. It is, however, essential to review the payment breakdown carefully to determine whether any inheritance property is included and to approach the matter with due caution.



Lee Sang-eun, Lawyer at Kyobo Life Insurance Comprehensive Asset Management and Financial Business Team


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing