Unable to Supplement Due to Prosecutor's Resignation

Supreme Prosecutors’ Office: “Omission Caused by Inexperience in Using KICS”

On April 29, 2026, the Seoul Eastern District Court dismissed the charges against Mr. A, who had been indicted for violations of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes (Dangerous Driving Resulting in Injury), and Mr. B, who had been prosecuted for violating the Road Traffic Act (drunk driving). In addition to Mr. A and Mr. B, four others also received dismissals of indictment from the Seoul Eastern District Court.


All six dismissed indictments were cases filed in February 2026 by former prosecutor Mr. C, who had worked at the Seoul Eastern District Prosecutors' Office. The reason for dismissal was the same in every case: the indictment lacked the signature or official seal of the prosecutor who initiated the charges. Mr. C had omitted his electronic signature when submitting the indictments through the Next-Generation Criminal Justice Information System (KICS). The court notified the prosecution of the missing signature on the hearing date, but by that time, Mr. C had already resigned, making it impossible to supplement the signature.


Article 57, Paragraph 1 of the Criminal Procedure Act requires that a prosecutor must sign or affix a seal to the indictment. The failure to include a signature renders the indictment invalid under Article 327, Paragraph 2 of the Criminal Procedure Act, which covers procedural violations that result in invalidity. The Supreme Court has also ruled indictments submitted to the court without the prosecutor’s signature or seal to be invalid (Supreme Court ruling 2019Do17150, pronounced on December 16, 2021).


Regarding this matter, a representative from the Supreme Prosecutors' Office explained, “Prosecutor C omitted the electronic signature procedure because he was unfamiliar with the new system.” With the implementation of criminal electronic litigation in October 2025, official approval for indictments submitted via KICS is conducted through electronic signatures rather than paper documentation. In the early stages of KICS adoption, there were system errors where signatures were not displayed despite prosecutors having signed, but this particular incident involved the prosecutor not performing the electronic signature at all.


However, the fact that indictments lacking electronic signatures were submitted to the court in this manner was due to an inadequate verification system for confirming whether a prosecutor’s signature was present. A representative from the Supreme Prosecutors’ Office stated, “An employee mistakenly sent an unsigned indictment to the court.” The court also commented, “A signature other than that of the prosecutor was entered on the indictment.”


The Supreme Prosecutors’ Office has since improved the system. According to a representative, “At that time, indictments could be submitted with only the signature of an administrative officer or prosecutorial staff member, even if the prosecutor's signature was missing. Now, the system has been improved so that indictments cannot be sent unless the prosecutor's signature is included.”


The Seoul Eastern District Prosecutors' Office has announced its intent to refile the six indictments that were dismissed. In a phone call with The Law Times, Mr. C stated, “As I am no longer in office, it is difficult to comment on matters that occurred during my tenure.”



Mina Han, The Law Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing