Exposed to Sunlight and Noise in a 40-Liter Tank...

Moved to a 2,500-Liter Large Tank Following Court Order

In Argentina, two goldfish displayed in a glass showcase at a sushi restaurant have been legally recognized by the court as "sentient beings" and subjects of rights. The court determined that their living conditions amounted to animal abuse.

The photo is not related to specific content of the article. Pixabay

The photo is not related to specific content of the article. Pixabay

View original image

Two Goldfish Forced to Live Exposed to Sunlight and Noise... Court Rules "Animal Abuse"

According to CNN on July 14 (local time), two goldfish named "Fede" and "Magui," which were kept at a sushi restaurant in Buenos Aires, Argentina, were recognized as holders of rights by a court verdict.


The two goldfish had been living in a 40-liter aquarium placed within a glass showcase at the restaurant's exterior. An animal rights organization, upon discovering that they were being raised in an environment directly exposed to sunlight and street noise, filed a lawsuit citing a violation of animal abuse laws.


An animal rescue expert from the anti-speciesism NGO "Abogadas y Abogados por los Derechos de los Animales" (Huellas Basicas), which initiated the lawsuit, criticized the inadequate living conditions by saying, "Putting two fish in a glass showcase is like locking up two polar bears in a sauna pen."


The court accepted the arguments of the animal rights group and ordered that the goldfish be moved to a more appropriate environment. Ultimately, the two fish were transferred to a 2,500-liter large tank under the care of experts.


However, this ruling specifically addressed the poor conditions in which the goldfish were kept and did not declare that keeping goldfish at home is illegal. Luciano Trupé, the lawyer handling this case, explained, "It is not illegal per se to keep fish in an aquarium," adding, "What is illegal is raising them in abusive or cruel conditions, such as in extremely confined spaces or by failing to provide proper food."

The photo is not related to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

The photo is not related to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

View original image

Recognition of "Animal Rights" Spreads Globally... Beyond Higher Mammals, Now to Fish

Meanwhile, attempts to recognize animals as legal subjects with rights, rather than mere objects, are ongoing worldwide. In Brazil in 2005, the first habeas corpus petition was filed on behalf of a chimpanzee named "Suíza." Subsequently, in Argentina, an orangutan named "Sandra" and a chimpanzee named "Cecilia" were recognized as "non-human persons" by the courts, while similar lawsuits involving highly intelligent animals such as elephants and dolphins have continued in the United States and Europe.


Until recently, animals other than humans were regarded as simple "property" or "objects" under legal systems. If someone injured a neighbor's dog, it was typically viewed as "property damage"—akin to damaging someone else's car—rather than harm to a living being.



Experts note that this ruling is significant in that the courts' recognition of rights, previously focused on higher mammals such as chimpanzees and orangutans, has now been extended to fish like goldfish.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing