[Public Voices]A Whale Introduced to the Pond Without Checking Its Size View original image

In the United States, there is an endless array of leveraged and inverse Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) that track daily returns by a multiple, and products that track individual stocks such as Tesla and Nvidia are also abundant.


However, there has never been any claim that these have shaken the S&P 500. A month and a half after similar products based on Samsung Electronics and SK hynix were listed in Korea, the entire KOSPI has been in turmoil. The annualized volatility of SK hynix has exceeded 110%, which is seven times that of the S&P 500, and the combined trading volume of these two stocks accounts for almost two-thirds of the market. The issue is not the products themselves, but rather the geometry of the market in which they are placed.


Three ratios are to blame. First, the index weighting. Nvidia accounts for 8% of the S&P 500, but Samsung Electronics and SK hynix make up 58% of the KOSPI200. Fluctuations in these stocks directly become fluctuations in the market. Second, it is about flow relative to channel width. In the U.S., the deep individual stock option markets and mechanical end-of-day dealer rebalancing are able to absorb shocks, but in Korea, where regulations have stunted the options and Exchange-Traded Notes (ETN) ecosystem, it is like a tsunami surging into a narrow waterway from the ocean. The strain on the less liquid futures market is reflected during the closing call auction of the spot market, resulting in roller-coaster volatility.


In particular, the rebalancing burden of inverse 2x products is three times greater than that of leverage products in the same direction. Third, stacking. On a market where index-linked leverage products were already effectively rebalancing these two stocks, individual stock products have now been layered on top. This kind of double amplification for the same stocks in the same time slot exists only in Korea.


On top of that, the sociology of demand is fueling the situation. Compressed growth has created a collective memory that wealth is not accumulated, but ridden. Whether in Gangnam apartments or cryptocurrencies, the moment social classes were divided was always one of boarding at the right time, and the neologism "Byeorak Geoji" (meaning "sudden pauper") is the epitome of this worldview. If meme stocks in the U.S. follow a grammar of play, leverage in Korea is governed by a grammar of making up for losses. The information environment of a single language and single platform has also contributed to approximately 14 trillion won in net purchases by individuals just six weeks after listing. While the rationale for this system change was to resolve the regulatory asymmetry between domestic and overseas listed ETFs, what was imported was only the product itself, not the environment in which it originally existed. An 8% index weighting, oceanic liquidity, and the cushion of options are all things that cannot be brought in. Rules can be imported, but ecosystems cannot be relocated.


That said, as some suggest, locking out new listings or halting further creation of these products is a poor choice. Blocking creation would paralyze arbitrage, leading to dislocation between price and actual value—a situation already learned with crude oil ETNs in 2020. The answer lies not in blocking supply, but in redesigning the flow.


First, the tracking price should be changed from the closing price to the average price of the pre-close period, so that dispersion of flows benefits the asset managers. Second, domestic brokerages should be permitted to increase their swap replication activities. To prevent outflow of fees via foreign investment banks (IBs), regulations on swaps and net capital ratio requirements need to be eased, so major brokerages can expand their risk-taking capacity. Third, the buffer zone should be restored by cultivating the individual equity options market and rationalizing ETN regulations. Fourth, the listing requirements for new products should be designed to link the size of the product directly to the index weight and liquidity of the underlying asset, as is naturally the case in the U.S.


The real problem was bringing a whale into a pond without first checking the pond's size. The task is not to kill the whale, but to widen the pond's waterways and to regulate the whale's size so it fits within the pond.



Park Youngseok, Professor Emeritus at Sogang University School of Business Administration


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing