Na Hong-jin's Tragedy of Ignorance Becomes a Tragedy of Avoidance
Turning Away from the Truth: How Often We Refuse to Face What We Know

※ This article contains many potential spoilers for the movie.


Director Na Hong-jin's new film "Hope" is, on the surface, structured much like "The Wailing" (2016). Both feature a middle-aged police officer as the protagonist and are set in a rural village inhabited by a mysterious, unidentified being. In both stories, rumors spread first, followed by tragedy, with the main character visiting the scene without any prior knowledge. However, this similar setup actually highlights sharp differences between the films. While Jonggu (played by Kwak Do-won) in "The Wailing" and Beomseok (played by Hwang Jung-min) in "Hope" begin from a similar starting point, they each break down in completely different ways.


Movie still cut from the film 'Hope'.

Movie still cut from the film 'Hope'.

View original image

Jonggu never learns the truth to the very end. He is never presented with grounds for judgment in the first place. It is a catastrophe born of a lack of information. Beomseok's case is different. After confirming the death of a young alien, he recognizes that the aliens are filled with grief and a desire for vengeance. He has some knowledge of the truth. Yet, when Seongae (played by Jung Hoyeon) tries to explain the circumstances of Seonggi's (played by Zo In-sung) death, Beomseok abruptly interrupts her. "Enough, stop talking, my mouth hurts." He doesn't stop because he is clueless; he stops because he can't bear the weight he must shoulder.


If "The Wailing" is an epistemological tragedy, "Hope" becomes an ethical tragedy from this point. Early in the film, the villagers are gripped by fear and attack before even beginning to understand what the alien is. The same thing happened during the mask crisis in early 2020. Panic buying started before the actual supply situation and demand were even grasped, and physical altercations broke out in front of pharmacies over line cutting. Fear overtook understanding, provoking action ahead of comprehension.


Even after understanding was reached, society remained shaken. According to a 2020 survey by the Seoul National University Graduate School of Public Health, cited by the National Human Rights Commission of Korea, respondents said they feared the social blame and criticism they would receive for being diagnosed with COVID-19 even more than they feared the infection itself. In reality, as individuals' movement records were made public in detail, there were more cases where people avoided testing or reporting symptoms even when they suspected they might be infected. It wasn't ignorance; rather, people had a suspicion and still avoided confirmation out of fear of the consequences.


Still cut from the movie 'Hope'.

Still cut from the movie 'Hope'.

View original image

The scene where Beomseok cuts Seongae off illustrates the same theme. Within Seongae's attempt to explain the causality behind Seonggi's death lies a truth Beomseok must accept. But as soon as Beomseok senses where those words will lead him, he turns away. While the tragedy of ignorance results from not knowing, the tragedy of avoidance comes from being afraid of the results even when you do know. Sometimes, instead of making a poor judgment due to ignorance, we close our own eyes and ears because we can't accept what we do know. This is why Beomseok’s dilemma feels strangely familiar.


This theme is reiterated in the final scene of the film. Both humans and aliens witness a massive ship from the sky explode. Afterward, the attitudes of each side sharply diverge. Beomseok says there is nothing he can do except run. In contrast, Maveiyo (Michael Fassbender) reveals his own heart—literally—demonstrating his determination to revive the deceased alien baby. Jor (Alicia Vikander) also speaks of the power that belief can hold. In the face of an incomprehensible situation, humans freeze and stop, while aliens move forward.


Here, the notion of hope referenced in the title is completely flipped. Humanity is left with nothing concrete to hold on to. Collapse begins not from the gigantic alien being, but from within the humans themselves. Hope is found not with those who abandon understanding, but with those who refuse to give up on it and continue pushing forward even when their understanding is incomplete. Ultimately, the question this film poses to its audience is about our own attitudes: when something feels too much to comprehend, are we, like Beomseok, cutting off the conversation? Are we, like those who postponed testing for fear of the result, turning away from confirmation because we are afraid?



Movie still cut from "Hope."

Movie still cut from "Hope."

View original image

Director Na has consistently depicted ignorance and helplessness in works such as "The Chaser" (2008), "The Yellow Sea" (2010), and "The Wailing." "Hope" takes this idea a step further. It no longer focuses on people collapsing out of ignorance, but on people willingly shutting themselves off even when they could have known and understood. The fact that such a choice feels so familiar is, in itself, the real question the film leaves us with.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing