The 'Samjeon-Nyx' Debate Spreads Across Industries
"Principles, Procedures, and Social Consensus Are Missing"
Fair Compensation and Distribution Emerge as Key Social Issues

Editor's NoteThe question of how to distribute corporate performance has now become a topic that goes beyond simple labor-management negotiations to encompass the entire industrial sector. The debate over performance-based bonuses linked to operating profit, which began in the semiconductor industry, has spread into the automotive, shipbuilding, and IT sectors, and evolved into demands from subcontractor unions for a share from primary contractors. However, the discussion remains focused only on how much more should be distributed, with little sign of any social consensus on who should receive the rewards based on which principles or procedures. While there is talk of adopting American-style performance compensation, the labor market flexibility or sector-level allocation criteria that support such a system in the U.S. are largely absent from the debate. Distributing bonuses without established principles is increasingly likely to cause not only internal disparities within companies, but also broader industrial and societal conflicts. The Asia Business Daily looks at the challenges posed by the 'N% performance bonus' debate for Korean society through interviews and columns featuring experts' opinions.

The performance-based compensation system linked to operating profit, as introduced by Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, is solidifying as a new standard for rewards, but there remains a lack of well-established grounds for the associated criteria. Experts view this debate as a starting point for examining what constitutes fair contribution and appropriate compensation.


Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

Experts first raised concerns about the removal of payout limits. Previous Over-Profit Incentive (OPI) schemes had an upper limit, but the Special Management Performance Bonus is now set without a cap, directly tied to operating profit. Previously, the upper limit served as a mechanism to acknowledge the contribution of external factors—such as market conditions and partner companies—that were reflected in performance. The elimination of this cap is now being criticized for producing significant side effects.


Lee Jonghun, Professor at Myongji University, stated, "The cap acts as a mechanism to distinguish between an individual worker's contribution and their surrounding circumstances," and added, "By removing this, disputes over fairness regarding contributions to performance or eligibility for compensation are bound to persist."


Another criticism is that the discussion is concentrated solely on distributing profits. While demands for allocation increase when results are strong, how to share burdens when performance weakens has not made it to the bargaining table. Despite borrowing from American reward standards, the employment structure remains rooted in domestic practices, creating an imbalance.


Park Cheolsung, Professor at Hanyang University, commented, "While many bonuses are paid out when there is strong performance, there is no corresponding system holding employees accountable when there are significant losses." He explained that in other countries, labor markets are more flexible, balancing rewards and responsibilities. He added that the scope of performance allocation should also be re-examined, noting that the results achieved in the Device Solutions (DS) division were not created exclusively by employees within that division.


['N% Bonus' Aftermath]① "Distribution and Conflict, New Principles Needed" - Urgent Analysis by Five Experts View original image

All panelists were skeptical about legally mandating how to distribute profits. The reason: even distinguishing between 'normal' and 'excess' profits is inherently difficult. However, there was consensus that it is also not a matter that can be left entirely to individual company negotiations. Park Myungjun, Senior Research Fellow at the Korea Labor Institute, argued, "The enterprise-level bargaining structure is working to exacerbate polarization," and insisted, "We need to establish standard principles based on industry type and job category." Professor Lee also pointed out, "At the very least, there should have been discussion within the semiconductor industry about how to set allocation criteria, but careful deliberation is needed, and such discussions were overdue."


Experts interpret the current debate as a signal that the entire distribution system needs to be overhauled, with the very legal character of performance-based bonuses, the role of labor unions, and the extent of shareholder rights all included in the discussion. Proposals also emerged about what share should be borne by companies, workers, shareholders, and the government, respectively. Participants in the interview included Park Myungjun, Senior Research Fellow at the Korea Labor Institute; Park Cheolsung, Professor at Hanyang University; Lee Jonghun, Professor Emeritus at Myongji University; Jeong Seungil, Policy Committee Member of the Welfare State Society; and Hwang Yongyeon, Director of Labor Policy at the Korea Employers Federation (listed in alphabetical order).


['N% Bonus' Aftermath]① "Distribution and Conflict, New Principles Needed" - Urgent Analysis by Five Experts View original image

-How do you evaluate the process of reaching agreement on performance-based bonuses?


▲Park Myungjun= We are entering a new era, yet existing systems have not functioned effectively. The artificial intelligence (AI) transition has created a semiconductor supercycle, and during the process of companies generating massive profits, labor and management's sole focus on enterprise-level collective bargaining has heightened conflict. This has stirred public skepticism about whether the results are socially equitable or if the methods are appropriate.


▲Park Cheolsung= Because bonuses can be autonomously determined by labor and management, it is not inherently wrong for them to reach an agreement. However, these two companies play an extremely large role in the Korean economy. Bonus decisions by these companies can significantly influence other businesses, SMEs, or even the youth labor market. I believe the unions may have leveraged their symbolic stature and influence to a certain extent. When considering possible ripple effects, it would have been better to also discuss the impact on partner companies, labor market disparities, and corporate competitiveness, not just distribution itself.


▲Hwang Yongyeon= The matter of distributing operating profit is not a working condition like wages. It is not a subject of collective bargaining; therefore, the very act of negotiating it is problematic. For the Labor Relations Commission to intervene legally, a dispute must exist—but whether performance-based bonuses qualify as such a dispute is questionable.


▲Jeong Seungil= Following the ideology of shareholder capitalism, some claim that all profits belong exclusively to shareholders, and that workers should keep their hands off. This makes no sense. For a joint-stock company to exist and develop, it is essential to distinguish a company from its shareholders and ensure that losses are not shifted onto shareholders. This is the principle of limited liability for shareholders. So why does this principle disappear when profits are generated?


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

-Is it feasible to legislate the distribution of excess profits?


▲Lee Jonghun= I do not believe it can be done by law, nor can it be confined to semiconductors. Circumstances can change at any time, so legislating this would be unwise. The rapidly evolving environment means that inflexibility—the inevitable consequence of legislation—would come at a high cost, as laws would not keep pace with change.


▲Hwang Yongyeon= The government may levy taxes on companies, but forcing them to share excess profits would infringe on property rights.


▲Park Cheolsung= The very term "excess profit" is too ambiguous to be legislated. Sometimes profits are high, sometimes meager, or even turn to loss. Distinguishing between what is 'normal' and what is 'excess' profit is extremely difficult. If society expects companies to share substantial profits, we must address how to design systemic or policy-based incentives, rather than resorting to legislation.


-How do you view the labor union's performance bonus demands in the context of primary contractor–subcontractor relationships?


▲Jeong Seungil= It is only right to include subcontracted workers. However, considering the tendencies of Samsung Electronics’ union members and executives, just demanding inclusion does not make it practical. There is no solidarity with workers at partner companies—instead, the union exists just to maximize individual gains. Only the shell of a labor union remains, and it can no longer be called a labor movement. It has been over 30 years since the labor movement lost its way with misguided ideology and direction. Although trade union law has significantly improved since the era of Chun Doo-hwan, today’s union characteristics are far removed from the solidarity and equality once pursued by the movement.


▲Park Cheolsung= This is a negotiation strictly between Samsung Electronics’ union and management. It would have been preferable to also consider issues pertaining to partner companies or subcontracted workers. However, since they are not union members and the union’s objective is to serve its members’ interests, this is not an irrational action as far as the union is concerned. Whether it is rational from a societal perspective is another matter. The substantial results achieved by Samsung Electronics were not the work of DS division employees alone. Employees at partner and subcontracted companies also contributed. If their contributions are not adequately compensated, that can reasonably be considered socially irrational.


▲Lee Jonghun= This is precisely why a bonus cap is necessary. The cap serves as a mechanism to distinguish an individual worker's contribution from external circumstances. The presence of a cap represents consensus that, no matter how successful a company is, setting bonuses above the level of individual contribution is unjust. However, removing the cap ensures that disputes about the fairness of contributions to performance and eligibility for rewards will persist. If we aim for sustainability and recognize the input of external actors, a cap is justified.


['N% Bonus' Aftermath]① "Distribution and Conflict, New Principles Needed" - Urgent Analysis by Five Experts View original image

-Can the approval of performance-based bonuses be mandated to take place at board or shareholder meetings?


▲Lee Jonghun= This is turning into a headache for boards because it involves the issuance of shares. If shareholders object, the company cannot award union-agreed shares as bonuses. Still, since it is stipulated in collective bargaining agreements with the union, the company is legally bound and must comply, which means they take on debt obligations vis-a-vis their employees. This can eventually lead to litigation, further complicating matters.


▲Park Cheolsung= Requiring a shareholder vote every time bonuses are set is exceedingly difficult and unrealistic. In the case of Samsung Electronics, the issue of shareholder meetings arose only because bonuses were to be paid in company stock. If the payment were in cash, there would be no need for a shareholder vote.


▲Hwang Yongyeon= The Commercial Act stipulates that decisions on allocating operating profits must be determined by the board or at shareholder meetings. In major U.S. big tech companies, these decisions are all made by the board—specifically, a remuneration committee consisting of executives and directors. In Germany, while such matters are discussed in the works council, prior approval is still required from the board, ensuring managerial oversight.


-As performance-based bonus demands spread across industries, is it possible to reach a social consensus?


▲Park Myungjun= Bonuses are not technically working conditions, yet they are negotiated at the company level, and this structure is driving polarization. If the guiding principle is "equal pay for equal work," then standard rules must be established by industry and job category. Unions must exercise bold leadership. Employee participation in management should also increase. An alternative mechanism—other than collective bargaining—should be sought. The government must reform laws and systems so labor and management can consult on such issues. Now is the time to fundamentally restructure labor relations after the large-scale labor struggles of 1987.


▲Hwang Yongyeon= Just two years ago, semiconductors didn’t attract much attention, but now we talk about a supercycle. Recently, Google issued bonds and SK hynix urgently raised capital via American Depositary Receipts (ADR)—these are moments of intense pressure for companies simply to survive. Against this backdrop, the debate over performance-based bonuses seems wholly out of touch with pressing realities.


▲Park Cheolsung= There is ongoing conflict because employees in the DS division receive much higher bonuses than those in the DX (Device eXperience) division, and similar demands are cropping up in other firms, further fueling labor-management strife. It's difficult to specify an appropriate boundary in numeric terms. If performance-based bonuses begin to be treated as a fixed right beyond companies’ ability to pay, that would be a problem. We could see reduced research and development (R&D) or capital investment, fewer new hires, and companies may even shy away from domestic production and investment, at which point the line would truly be crossed.


['N% Bonus' Aftermath]① "Distribution and Conflict, New Principles Needed" - Urgent Analysis by Five Experts View original image

-What is the broader socio-economic significance of the conflict over performance-based bonuses?


▲Lee Jonghun= This debate has thrown the concepts of fair compensation and fair distribution into the spotlight. Even if the performance comes from semiconductors, the contributors are not limited only to those working in that field. In the past, losses in semiconductors were offset by profits from mobile phones—that was the reality. This has sparked a broader discussion of what constitutes fair contribution and appropriate reward.


▲Park Cheolsung= Paying out large bonuses is not inherently a negative phenomenon. Just as in Silicon Valley, it can be a way to secure talent and provide motivation. The problem arises when such benefits are concentrated only among a handful of ultra-high-performing companies, or if opportunities to enter such companies are severely limited. If young people have little chance of joining top-tier firms, it becomes a real issue. The focus should be on how fairly rewards reflect ability and achievement, and whether people have real and equitable access to those opportunities.



This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing