Embezzlement Charges Against Kim Geonhee Special Probe Defendant

Acquittal and Dismissal in Both Lower Courts

Supreme Court Upholds Final Ruling

Kim Yesung, known as 'Kim Geonhee's Butler,' who was indicted by the special prosecutor Min Jungki's team on charges of embezzling company funds, has had his acquittal and dismissal of charges confirmed by the Supreme Court.

Kim Ye-seong, 'Kim Geonhee's Assistant,' Attending the Pretrial Detention Hearing. Yonhap News Agency.

Kim Ye-seong, 'Kim Geonhee's Assistant,' Attending the Pretrial Detention Hearing. Yonhap News Agency.

View original image

The Supreme Court's Second Division (Presiding Justice Oh Kyungmi) on the 16th dismissed the special prosecutor's appeal against Kim, who was charged with embezzlement under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes and occupational embezzlement, and upheld the lower court's ruling of acquittal and dismissal of the indictment.


The so-called 'Butler Gate' refers to allegations that Kim, pointed to as the house manager for first lady Kim Geonhee’s family, raised approximately 18.4 billion won in investment from Kakao Mobility, Shinhan Bank, Kiwoom Securities and others through IMS Mobility (formerly B My Car), a company he established and operated, with suspicions that part of the investment funds were funneled to Kim Geonhee's side.


Kim was tried on charges of embezzlement after he sold IMS Mobility shares held by InnoBest Korea, which he effectively managed, for around 4.6 billion won in 2023, and then paid 2.43 billion won of that amount to his business partner, IMS Mobility CEO Cho Youngtak, under the false pretense of a loan.


He was also accused of using funds from InnoBest Korea and other companies he managed for personal purposes, such as his spouse’s salary, his child’s tuition, and credit card payments.


The first trial court acquitted him of the 2.43 billion won embezzlement charge, citing insufficient evidence of a crime. Since CEO Cho paid back the borrowed amount as investment funds, resulting in a successful investment and the sale of InnoBest Korea's shares for about 4.6 billion won, the court found it difficult to recognize Kim's intention to unlawfully appropriate the funds.


For the additional personal embezzlement charges, the court dismissed the indictment on the grounds that these were not subject to investigation under the Kim Geonhee Special Prosecution Act.


The appellate court upheld the first ruling. The bench determined that Kim's remaining embezzlement charges were neither related to first lady Kim Geonhee, nor to the receipt or use of IMS Mobility investment funds. Furthermore, the timing and methods of the alleged crimes were different, and thus did not constitute "related cases" or "related criminal acts" under the Special Prosecutor Act.


The logic was that, if all similar crimes were deemed subject to special prosecution merely due to their category, the investigative scope of the special prosecutor would become excessively broad, undermining the legislative intent of the special law.



The Supreme Court also stated, "The lower court did not deviate from the bounds of logical reasoning, experience, or the discretion of free evaluation of evidence, nor did it make any errors in its legal interpretation of unlawful intent in embezzlement or matters related to the scope of investigation under the Kim Geonhee Special Prosecution Act," thus dismissing the special prosecutor's appeal.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing