Retroactive Application of Amended Law Following Constitutional Court's Unconstitutionality Ruling

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court has ruled that assets given as a token of gratitude to a cohabitant who provided care for decades should be excluded from the compulsory share restitution claim. This ruling proactively acknowledges the retroactive effect of the amended law, following the Constitutional Court's decision that the previous Civil Act, which did not recognize contributions when calculating compulsory shares, was unconstitutional.


According to the legal community on July 15th, the Supreme Court's Third Division (Presiding Justice Oh Seokjun) overturned the previous court's partial ruling in favor of plaintiff A against defendant B in an inheritance restitution lawsuit and remanded the case to the Daegu District Court.


The case originated from a donation made by the deceased, who passed away in November 2022. B had lived with the deceased for about 27 years, providing direct care and personally covering costs such as nursing home fees and mobile phone bills. As a gesture of gratitude, the deceased made a gift of assets to B prior to passing. However, A, the statutory co-heir, filed a lawsuit claiming that the assets B received infringed upon their compulsory share of the inheritance.


Both the first and second instance courts regarded the assets B received as special benefits and included them in the calculation base for the compulsory share. At the time, the court sided with A, applying the previous Civil Act provision that did not apply the co-heirs' contributions to the compulsory share system.


However, the Supreme Court did not accept this approach. The justices pointed out that, in April 2024, the Constitutional Court issued an unconstitutionality ruling on the previous Civil Act provision that failed to account for contributions in the compulsory share system, and that subsequently, the Civil Act was amended in March of the same year. The newly introduced Article 1008 of the Civil Act provides that "a gift or bequest made as compensation for special support or a significant contribution to the maintenance or increase of the decedent's property through means such as cohabitation or nursing shall be excluded from special benefits."



Notably, the justices held that this new law should be applied retroactively to cases that were pending at the time of the Constitutional Court decision. "Because this case was ongoing in the courts at the time of the unconstitutionality ruling, the new law, which has eliminated the unconstitutional provision, should apply," the court stated. "If B’s support contributions were commensurate with the gift received, the assets should have been excluded from special benefits; thus, the previous court misinterpreted the law by applying the old statute."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing