Operation Models of Military Academies Abroad

[Series] Will the Repeated Military Academy Mergers Succeed This Time? View original image


The operation methods of military academies in foreign countries vary widely. However, there is a common standard. In countries with an active-duty military force of more than 1 million, such as the United States and China, the army, navy, and air force academies are all operated separately. This is because, with a large number of cadets, integrated education is realistically unsuitable. On the other hand, in countries with smaller militaries, there are many cases where military academies are integrated due to limited budget resources.


The More Troops, the More Likely Separate Academies


The United States is a prime example of a country that operates separate military academies for each branch. The United States Military Academy is located near West Point, New York; the Naval Academy is in Annapolis near Washington, D.C.; and the Air Force Academy is in Colorado Springs.


Competition for admission is fierce. Acceptance rates are 10% for both the Army and Air Force Academies, and 8% for the Naval Academy. This is on par with Ivy League schools, which are considered the most prestigious private universities in the United States. The reason these cannot be compared to military academies in Korea comes down to scale. For example, the United States Military Academy alone has more than 4,000 cadets. Significant investment is made in recruiting outstanding faculty. After commissioning, officers are required to complete the Joint Professional Military Education (JPME) program, gaining additional joint training in relevant positions.


Integrated Training After Separate Education Is Essential


The United Kingdom (with a military strength of about 140,000) and France (about 260,000), both of which possess nuclear weapons, also operate separate academies for each branch, but their education systems place a strong emphasis on integrated training after graduation. In the United Kingdom, cadets enroll in each branch's academy for less than a year after graduating from a regular university, known as the "4+1" model. The military academy portion is, therefore, brief. In France, after completing a two-year preparatory course for the Grandes Ecoles, cadets enter a three-year military academy. The Grandes Ecoles are elite institutions established by the French government to cultivate top talent, including Sciences Po, HEC Paris, the National School of Administration, and the École Normale Supérieure. Promising candidates undergo short, intensive military training, and after commissioning, some are selected to return for undergraduate studies as needed. The Russian military, with 1.3 million troops, conducts integrated training, but separates its service branches within the academies for junior officer education.


Canada's Integrated Model Is the Most Successful


There are also countries that operate integrated military academies, including Japan, Venezuela, Australia, and Canada. The Canadian military is regarded as having the most successful model of an integrated military academy. Initially, Canada separated its army, navy, and air force academies, but in 1968 unified its educational system into the Royal Military College (RMC) to promote jointness. Admissions standards have risen in recent years, with successful applicants earning scores between 90 and 95 out of 100, and the acceptance rate is reportedly around 15%. In 2011, service branches were reinstated to address declining morale, but the RMC system was retained.



Thailand, on the other hand, separated its military academies after initially operating them as an integrated school. Thailand once trained army, navy, air force, and even police officers together at the Armed Forces Academies Preparatory School (AFAPS). However, a coup took place among AFAPS alumni. Instead of fostering checks and balances between the branches and police, a culture of collusion developed. Consequently, due to concerns over repeated coup risks and management issues, Thailand decided to split the academies once again.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing