Pros and Cons of Military Academy Integration Remain at an Impasse

[Feature] Will This Attempt at a "Recurring Military Academy Merger" Succeed? View original image


The Korea Military Academy and the Korea Naval Academy were both established in 1946, one year after liberation. The Korea Air Force Academy opened three years later, in 1949. Since their founding, each military academy has served as a major pillar of national security for nearly 80 years. As a result, any issue related to these academies tends to be highly sensitive for their graduates.


KMA Alumni Association Protests "Rushed Merger and Relocation"


The strongest opposition is coming from the Korea Military Academy. In a statement, the KMA Alumni Association said, "The government has confirmed and is urgently pushing forward a plan to merge the academies and relocate the KMA to a regional area by 2028," and requested a complete reexamination, stating, "Instead of a rushed merger, a process of public discussion and deliberation is necessary." Thirteen former Chiefs of Staff, including former Defense Minister and KMA Superintendent Han Minkoo, expressed concern, saying, "The competitiveness of an academy depends on securing excellent cadets and faculty, and it is not difficult to foresee what effect moving and dispersing the academies may have on application rates and quality of education."


Contradiction Between Marine Corps Separation and Education Integration


Opponents argue that integrating the academies would disadvantage non-academy officers. Currently, 15% of military officers in Korea are military academy graduates, while 85% are commissioned from non-academy sources. According to the Joint Chiefs of Staff Personnel Management Instruction No. 3078, officers who wish to serve on the Joint Chiefs of Staff must complete a specialized joint education program. If joint education is managed by a military academy, the argument follows that non-academy officers would effectively be deprived of the opportunity for joint training.


They also say the plan conflicts with the move toward a four-branch military system that separates the Marine Corps. In June, President Lee Jaemyung visited the Yeonpyeong unit and stated, "The quasi-four-branch system is both the long-held wish of the Marine Corps and my longstanding conviction, and it was a presidential campaign pledge." The contradiction, they point out, is in separating the military branches while integrating their academies.


Professor Hong Kyuduck, Professor Emeritus at Sookmyung Women's University, said, "Since National Defense University is already offering integrated education, it would be sufficient to simply expand the range of courses and faculty to include all three branches."


Eliminating Political Interventions Using Academy Cohort Culture


The core of the argument for integration focuses on the unique culture created by having specialized academies and a strong cohort tradition. Graduates' emphasis on tradition and identity is believed to have led to military involvement in politics. The 5·16 military coup, the 12·12 military rebellion, and the 5·18 Gwangju Massacre are cited as representative examples. The Lee Jaemyung administration also points out that the 12·3 martial law was deeply influenced by the military academy network.


Administrative inefficiency is also cited as a major reason. Each service academy currently trains about 300 cadets per grade. Each academy also employs around 700 faculty and staff members, including a three-star general who serves as superintendent. When their facilities, land, and separate support systems are considered, organizational size and budget increase even further. This means that the operating expenses for officer training organizations are disproportionately large.


Most Professors Lack a PhD


Concerns have also been raised about the academy teaching staff. While each military academy refuses to disclose this information citing privacy, less than half of their instructors hold a doctoral degree. According to National Assembly audit data from 2015, only 46% at the Korea Military Academy and 39% at the Korea Naval Academy had a PhD. This is in stark contrast to the background of distinguished international political scientist John Mearsheimer, who is a graduate of West Point and served as an Air Force officer for five years.


The Korea Military Academy continued to use a decade-old North Korea studies textbook until 2016. At that time, the textbook in use had been published in 2006. Although North Korea had conducted six nuclear tests, the textbook contained no information about North Korea's nuclear program. The academy replaced the textbook only after this issue was raised in this newspaper's December 27, 2016 edition.



Former lawmaker Kim Jongdae of the Justice Party said, "There was a time when the Joint Chiefs of Staff itself requested the integration of the military academies, and it was the Army that took the initiative." He added, "Rather than dividing into pros and cons depending on circumstances, decisions should be made for the future of the armed forces."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing