"Selected, Then Re-selected?... GH’s U-turn on Public Rental Housing Selection Leaves Applicants Confused"
Notice Reversed About 10 Days After Candidate Announcement
Conflict Emerges Among Applicants, Escalating Confusion
Reversal Applied Not Only to Priority Supply But to All Housing Types
Gyeonggi Housing & Urban Development Corporation (GH) has come under criticism for a lack of fairness after it selected candidates required to submit documents for the Dasan Jigeum A3 integrated public rental housing using a lottery. GH changed its selection method at a late stage to a "comprehensive review of all applicants," which in turn caused opposition from those who had already been selected as document candidates, creating further confusion.
Aerial photo of the new headquarters building of Gyeonggi Housing & Urban Development Corporation (GH). The Asia Business Daily DB
View original imageAccording to GH on July 15, the corporation accepted applications for each supply category over a four-day period from June 16 to 19. For Dasan Jigeum A3 integrated public rental housing, a total of 518 units will be provided: 284 units for priority supply, 188 units for general supply, and 46 units for housing-disadvantaged groups. In total, 8,030 households applied for the priority category, 10,938 for the general category, and 564 for housing-disadvantaged supply. On July 3, GH selected and notified 1,386 households as candidates required to submit documents.
Problems followed soon after. Some applicants who were excluded from the document submission list contacted GH, at which point the corporation admitted that it had selected candidates by lottery, sparking controversy.
According to the public notice for the tenant recruitment, in the event of competition for priority supply, applicants with children under 2 years old and those with higher total scores should be selected in order of priority. The announcement only stated that if the number of applicants exceeded available units, some would be chosen as document submission candidates, but did not specify the actual selection process, leading GH to conduct a random draw and causing procedural concerns.
Applicants excluded from the document submission process argued, "Even newborn households, applicants with severe disabilities, and those with high scores—who should have received priority review according to the notice—never got the chance for a price review," and claimed that "procedural fairness has been undermined." They pointed out that key matters such as the tenant selection method should be included in the recruitment announcement, but the random draw system was not stated, making it problematic.
GH reversed its decision on July 13 in response to these objections, saying it would review the entire selection process from scratch. It announced it would verify documents for all 8,030 applicants for the priority category—including 684 who had already been selected as document candidates. The corporation clarified, "After announcing the first batch of candidates required to submit documentation, we decided to expand the qualification verification to all applicants to fully implement the scoring-based ranking principle defined by law. Therefore, we will pre-screen every applicant."
This has now led to backlash from those who were originally selected. Lee Yonghwa, who had been selected as a document candidate for general supply, said, "I was very happy to have been chosen since I couldn't even register a marriage due to not being able to secure a newlywed home. But with the sudden change in the announcement, I'm confused. Since I don't have children, I now have even less chance."
Another candidate for document submission, identified as Mr. A, commented, "It is a clear violation of the principle of the protection of trust to pass the consequences of an administrative error by a public institution onto successful candidates who went through the official procedures, thereby distorting competition. The method should not infringe on the rights of those already selected."
Due to the reversal, GH will now review documents for all applicants, totaling 19,532 households, including those already selected as document candidates.
However, it appears that the corporation also faced confusion due to the lack of precise guidelines for selecting document candidates. A GH official explained, "New conditions, such as children under 2 years old, were introduced early last year, but without detailed guidelines since then, we left the candidate selection process more open." Under the Special Act on Public Housing, the selection method for document candidates can be determined by the project implementer.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The GH official added, "The corporation believed that selecting a certain range based on identical standards, without considering unverified self-reported information, would be fairer; however, some applicants voiced the opinion that the selection process should include all applicants. We concluded that including everyone in the selection process would maximize both fairness and procedural acceptance."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.