[Inside Chodong]No Exception to the Law: The Special Exemption for Relatives Must End View original image

The only exception is for "family." Under Korean criminal law, anyone who harbors or aids a criminal, or destroys evidence in connection with a criminal case, is subject to punishment. However, a special exemption applies if a relative commits such an act for the sake of family.


This law, which has remained unchanged for over 70 years since its enactment in 1953, has come under scrutiny following the Gwangju high school girl murder case. The suspect Jang Yun-gi's father destroyed key evidence, but due to the family exemption, he is likely to avoid criminal liability.


The family exemption has triggered widespread public outrage. In the infamous "Molar Daddy" Lee Young-hak case, his mother burned the victim's clothes to destroy evidence, yet she was not investigated. More recently, in the investigation involving First Lady Kim Keon-hee, it was found that her family members helped hide jewelry, but they avoided prosecution.


This exemption is also widely applied in minor criminal cases. Parents who helped a suspect escape, a wife who deleted text messages recording her husband’s crimes, and a father who tried to delete black box footage in his son’s theft case—all were exempt from criminal responsibility.


However, the family exemption, which is essentially an automatic acquittal that cannot even be properly reviewed, needs to be reformed. The current system goes beyond "understanding the family" and is closer to "granting unconditional immunity to family members."


As a result, this overprotection of suspects' rights, without regard for the victim, is undermining public trust in law enforcement. The delay in uncovering the truth and the increased difficulty in restoring victims’ rights are also causing significant harm to the public interest.


The traditional notion that "it is excessive to punish acts driven by the instinct to protect family" is no longer in line with the times. Similarly, the provision that "the state should not exercise its power to punish in cases of property crimes among family members, regardless of the victim’s wishes"—known as the family property crime exemption—was abolished last year.


The Constitutional Court’s decision that this provision was unconstitutional was based on the view that "in the absence of state intervention, it is difficult for the victim to recover." The current debate over the family exemption must be approached with the same logic. As family structures evolve and the definition of kinship becomes more ambiguous, the state should not evade its duty to realize justice simply because of blood ties.


If society needs consensus on punishing acts intended to protect family, legislative revision could give courts the discretion to consider such factors. Instead of granting blanket immunity, the courts could weigh these factors during sentencing. In Japan, with a culture similar to Korea’s, the courts assess the circumstances and the status of the individual involved to determine whether an exemption is warranted.



Now it is up to the National Assembly. As both the ruling and opposition parties have introduced bills to abolish the family exemption, the starting point for discussion should be the principle that the law exists to protect victims, not perpetrators. Amending this decades-old exemption is not targeting families—it is about restoring trust in the law.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing