Law Society Recommends Using "Judge" Instead of "My Lord"

British Common Law Traditions Remain... Reform Sparks Debate

In Uganda, an attempt to change long-standing courtroom practices—such as addressing judges as "My Lord" or "My Lady," a tradition inherited from the British colonial era—has sparked a heated debate after facing strong opposition from the judiciary.


On July 10 (local time), the BBC reported that the Uganda Law Society (ULS) had recently recommended that its member lawyers use more universal forms of address, such as "Mr. Judge" or "Madam Judge," instead of "My Lord" or "My Lady" when speaking to judges in court.


Across many African countries that adopted the British legal system, there has been a long-standing debate over whether to maintain colonial-era legacies such as robes, wigs, and traditional courtroom titles.


Uganda, which became a British protectorate in 1894, was ruled by Britain for nearly 70 years. During this period, Britain introduced its own systems in administration, education, and the judiciary, embedding British customary law and courtroom culture. Even after gaining independence in 1962, Uganda retained most of its existing judicial system and continues to operate a legal framework based on British common law to this day.


The photo is not directly related to the content of the article. Pixabay Pixabay

The photo is not directly related to the content of the article. Pixabay Pixabay

View original image

As a result, titles such as "My Lord" and "My Lady," as well as traditional robes and courtroom etiquette used to address senior judges in British courts, have continued to this day. While such honorifics were widely used in Britain at the time—given that many senior judges were from the aristocracy—criticism has persisted since independence that these practices are authoritarian legacies of the colonial era.


The ULS argued, "These expressions are honorifics that originated in Britain's feudal and colonial eras, and they may foster the perception that judges are superior to ordinary citizens." The association also called for an end to the practice of lawyers and litigants bowing deeply to judges in court, stating that people should present their arguments upright, as free citizens.


However, the Ugandan judiciary firmly rejected the law society's guidelines, stating that forms of address and procedures used in the courtroom are matters for the judiciary to decide independently, and cannot be unilaterally changed by external organizations.


James Ereemye, spokesperson for the Ugandan judiciary, told the BBC, "The law society has no authority to instruct judges on what to do or how they should be addressed," adding, "The courts will maintain their existing courtroom etiquette going forward."


However, he clarified that this does not mean discussions about institutional reforms are off the table, stating, "If an issue is identified, it should be proposed through appropriate consultation, and if the argument is sufficiently convincing, it could become policy."



Meanwhile, in Kenya in 2011, then-Chief Justice Willy Mutunga drew attention when he criticized the tradition of wearing robes and wigs, opting to take his oath of office in a business suit instead.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing