Management and Budget Review Committee, Including External Members, Underway
First Committee Meeting Recently Held
Safety Management Evaluation a Key Variable for Industrial Bank of Korea
Attention on Whether Korea Development Bank Will Maintain 'A Grade' for Five Consecutive Years

The financial authorities have begun the process of evaluating last year's management performance of state-run banks, including Korea Development Bank, Export-Import Bank of Korea, and Industrial Bank of Korea. The results of this evaluation will affect not only employee performance bonuses, but also next year's budget and staffing levels. The final ratings for each institution are expected to be announced later this month.


Financial Authorities Begin Management Evaluation of KDB, Eximbank, and IBK... 'Report Cards' to Be Released This Month View original image

According to the financial industry on July 13, the Financial Services Commission recently launched a management evaluation of Korea Development Bank, Export-Import Bank of Korea, and Industrial Bank of Korea. Since 2007, the Financial Services Commission has carried out annual management evaluations of state-run banks and related institutions under its jurisdiction.


The evaluation results are determined after a review by the 'Management and Budget Review Committee,' which is composed of external experts. Recently, it has been confirmed that the first committee meeting was held, where the institutions under review presented their management performance and key issues to the committee members. Since the process generally involves two rounds of review, the final ratings for each institution are expected to be announced within this month.


The evaluation results are classified into six grades, ranging from the highest S grade to A, B, C, D, and E. Employee performance bonuses also vary according to the grade received: S grade corresponds to 200% of base salary, A grade 180%, B grade 150%, and C grade 110%. Since the evaluation results are also used as reference material for the evaluation of the institution head and for approval of the following year's budget and staffing plan, the institutions have a strong interest in the outcome.


This year, attention is focused on the performance of Industrial Bank of Korea, which received a B grade for the first time in the previous evaluation. It is known that Industrial Bank of Korea did not receive favorable scores in internal controls, as an improper loan of 88.2 billion won involving incumbent executives and employees was uncovered in an inspection by the Financial Supervisory Service early last year.


This year, safety management is also expected to be a burden. Industrial Bank of Korea received a 'Poor' (4th grade) rating in the Ministry of Economy and Finance's '2025 Public Institution Safety Management Grade Review.' The Public Institution Safety Management Grading System comprehensively evaluates the safety management capabilities and standards of public institutions, focusing on those where safety management at workplaces and construction sites is crucial. Accidents at subcontractor worksites involved in contracted projects are also included in the evaluation.


The management evaluation by the Financial Services Commission is conducted separately from the public institution management evaluation carried out by the Ministry of Economy and Finance and the Public Institution Management Committee. However, the evaluation criteria are similar in that they reflect not only management performance but also various incidents and accidents. An official from the financial authorities explained, "The evaluation criteria are similar to those used by the Public Institution Management Committee." Previously, Korea Asset Management Corporation (KAMCO) received a 'Poor' rating in the Ministry of Economy and Finance's public institution management evaluation, due to deaths and multiple accidents at contracted construction sites.


The issue of total personnel expenses is not expected to have a significant impact on this year's evaluation of state-run banks. The Financial Services Commission had previously allowed Industrial Bank of Korea to pay unpaid allowances even if it exceeded the total personnel expense limit, and decided to recognize this as an exception in the management evaluation. Korea Development Bank and Export-Import Bank of Korea explained that they have no unpaid allowances due to the total personnel expense limit.



There is also interest in whether Korea Development Bank will maintain its A grade for a fifth consecutive year, or even achieve the S grade. Korea Development Bank received an A grade for four years in a row up to the previous evaluation. Export-Import Bank of Korea also received an A grade last year. A financial industry official said, "The management evaluation grade impacts not only employee performance bonuses, but also the management performance of the institution head and the operation of next year’s budget. For state-run banks, it is important not only to achieve profitability and policy finance performance, but also to defend against any point deductions stemming from internal controls or safety management."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing