Lower Courts' Guilty Verdict Overturned and Case Remanded

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News

View original image

Even if someone uses abusive language toward another person in front of their parents, the requirement of "publicity" for defamation cannot be considered fulfilled if there is little likelihood that the content would be communicated to the outside. This is according to a recent Supreme Court ruling.


According to the legal community on July 10, the Supreme Court's third division (presiding Justice Lee Heung-gu) recently overturned a lower court's guilty verdict in the appeal trial of Mr. A, who had been indicted on charges of defamation, and remanded the case to the Seosan Branch of the Daejeon District Court.


Mr. A was brought to trial on charges of using abusive language toward his neighbor's son, B (age 15), during a dispute over a land boundary in a village in Seosan, South Chungcheong Province, in May 2023. It is known that Mr. A's parents were present at the scene at the time.


The lower courts in the first and second trials found Mr. A guilty. The courts recognized the condition of "publicity," which is required for a defamation conviction, on the grounds that those present at the scene could be deemed "an unspecified large number of people" in relation to the victim, or, even if not, that there was a possibility that the abusive language could be communicated to others through them.


However, the Supreme Court's judgment was different. The Supreme Court stated, "Even if a remark is made to a small number of people individually, the requirement of publicity can be recognized if there is an objective possibility that it could be communicated to others. However, the fact that a remark was made only to a specific few is a strong factor against recognizing publicity." The Court continued, "In this case, the only people who heard the abusive language were the victim's father and the defendant's parents, and there is no evidence that the defendant's parents relayed this to others or that any other residents were nearby at the time."



The Court further added, "Even from the perspective of the defendant's parents, there is little likelihood that they would communicate the abusive language, which their child expressed harshly during a dispute, to others around them."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing