[Baking Typewriter] Monsters Are Not Dead, They Have Simply Become Evidence
Isanhwa's "Modern Monster Hoaxes"
The Modern History of Belief as Told Through Hydras, Mermaids, and Fake Fossils
Hamburg, 1735. A hydra with multiple heads was placed before a naturalist. It was a moment when a mythical monster entered a glass display case. But Carl Linnaeus’s eyes stopped not on the creature, but first on its teeth and skin. The teeth looked as if they belonged to a weasel or a ferret, and the body was snakeskin. It was an object pieced together from parts of various animals. He concluded it was a fake. The monster appeared to be dead. But what truly died that day was not the monster itself; it was the old method of making people believe in monsters. In the place once supported by legend and scripture, the ruler of science had arrived.
Afterwards, the monsters vanished from forests and seas and instead found new places to reside. Inside museum glass cases, the pages of newspapers, photographic plates, and the podiums of academic conferences. While monsters of the past lived on through tales passed down, modern monsters arrived accompanied by statements of "I saw it," photographs, and explanations claiming "verification is underway." Faith did not weaken, it merely changed its form. The history of this change in form is precisely what the book "The Great Modern Monster Hoax" focuses on.
The Fiji Mermaid reveals this structure in the most blatant way. In the 1840s in New York, P. T. Barnum exhibited an object that appeared to be the fusion of a monkey and a fish as a mermaid. It was not a beautiful mermaid, but a shriveled and grotesque thing. Still, crowds gathered. What Barnum sold was not the mermaid itself, but the opportunity for doubt. Even while thinking, "there's no way it's real," people still yearned to see it for themselves. Tickets are not sold on faith alone; they are sold on doubt as well.
In front of the Cardiff Giant, doubt took on a more distinctly American face. In 1869, a ten-foot "petrified man" was unearthed at a farm in Cardiff, New York State. Was it evidence of a biblical giant, or an elaborate sculpture? Scientists, ministers, spectators, and showmen all gathered under the same tent. The giant merely lay there, but in truth, the only thing moving was people’s interpretations. Those who wanted to believe saw biblical evidence; those who doubted saw the craftsmanship of trickery; and showmen saw the queues of spectators. Falsehood cannot survive for long on its own. It endures when it calls forth both those who wish to believe and those who wish to expose it.
In 1842, the "Fiji Mermaid" was exhibited at P. T. Barnum's American Museum. It was not a beautiful mermaid but a bizarre specimen that looked like a monkey and fish stitched together. Barnum sold the suspicion that it might be "real" rather than a mermaid. Peabody Museum, Harvard University
View original imageBy the time we come to the case of the Piltdown Man, amusement is mixed with discomfort. This time, it was not a carnival tent but the authority of science that was deceived. The fossil, presented in Britain in 1912 as the "missing link" in human evolution, was revealed in 1953 to be a fake. The skull and jawbone belonged to different beings, the teeth had been filed to look human, and the bones were stained to appear ancient. Science was fooled. And it was science that eventually unmasked the truth. This contradiction matters. The modern period chased out monsters but also established an authority that monsters could borrow.
At this point, Lee Sanhwa focuses more on the machinery of belief than on the swindler. True to his background as an author of science fiction, he does not instantly dismiss the impossible. He examines the conditions under which the impossible begins to seem plausible. The black-and-white illustrations by Choi Jaehoon also work in this direction. Things already revealed as fakes return as images. The reader knows: the hydra is an artifact, the mermaid is a construct, the giant is a hoax. And yet, we look anyway. The lifespan of a monster outlasts the truth.
Ultimately, reading this book is not an act of erasing monsters one by one. Rather, it is about identifying the habits of humanity left behind wherever a monster is erased. People are not adept at enduring the unknown. When confronted by unexplained gaps, they insert stories; when stories are weak, they attach photos; when photos become blurry, they call in experts. Monsters are not merely products of ignorance. Even in those moments when knowledge tries to prove itself, monsters are born.
Today, we do not believe in hydras. Nor do we believe in the Fiji Mermaid or the Cardiff Giant. But we often pause before photographs, data, search results, and expert commentary. This is not to say that all of these are falsehoods. On the contrary, because they come packaged in such convincing forms, we find them easy to believe. The modern age did not put an end to monsters; it taught them how to take the form of evidence. Monsters have not died. They have simply acquired a more modern face.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The Great Modern Monster Hoax | Written by Lee Sanhwa | Illustrated by Choi Jaehoon | Galmaenamu | 512 pages
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.