"Simple Lack of Legal Knowledge, Not a Valid Defense"

An accomplice of an organization that carried out so-called "private retaliation" crimes on behalf of numerous unspecified clients has been sentenced to prison in the appellate trial as well.


The Criminal Appellate Division 3-1 of the Seoul Southern District Court (Presiding Judges Jang Yunseon, Cho Kyuseol, and Yoo Hwanwoo) on July 9 dismissed the appeal of Mr. Lee (33), who was indicted and detained on charges of home invasion and property damage, and upheld the original sentence of six months in prison.


Seoul Southern District Court. Photo by Jiye Lee

Seoul Southern District Court. Photo by Jiye Lee

View original image

The court rejected the argument by Lee’s side that he should be exonerated on the grounds that he was unaware his actions were illegal, which would provide grounds for justification (circumstances where the law exceptionally does not consider an act unlawful). Article 16 of the Criminal Act states that if there is a justifiable reason for mistakenly believing that one's actions are not a crime, punishment does not apply.


The court stated, "When the defendant entered the victims’ residences, he was sufficiently aware of the illegality of his actions," adding, "The defendant’s claim that he 'did not know' is simply ignorance of the law and not something that can be excused by the defendant’s own perception." The court further noted, "As for the property damage, this is also not determined by the defendant’s own awareness, so it is difficult to see this as a misunderstanding of the law regarding the establishment of the crime," and concluded, "There is no reason to consider the original sentence unfair."


Mr. Lee was indicted and detained on charges of breaking into an officetel in Siheung, Gyeonggi Province, in January, where he wrote abusive language with red spray paint on the entrance and nearby walls of the victim’s residence, scattered food waste, and distributed flyers containing the victim’s photograph. On the same day in Gwangjin-gu, Seoul, he also entered a building using the communal entrance code provided by an unidentified individual known as “Team Leader Min,” sprayed red paint, and threw filth inside.


According to the investigation, Mr. Lee, after applying for personal rehabilitation due to credit card arrears and searching for a way to cover living expenses, was proposed the crimes by the unidentified “Team Leader Min” and participated in return for money.



Previously, the first-instance court stated, "The victims must have felt significant anxiety and fear," and added, "If crimes committed for payment are not strictly punished, copycat crimes may become widespread," before sentencing him to six months in prison.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing