Lower Courts: "Refusal of Collective Bargaining Is an Unfair Labor Practice"
Supreme Court: "No Obligation for Principal Contractors to Bargain with Subcontractor Unions Before the Yellow Envelope Act"

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court has ruled that it cannot be considered an unfair labor practice for a courier headquarters (principal contractor) to refuse a request for collective bargaining from delivery workers affiliated with its agencies (subcontractors).


On July 9, the Supreme Court's Third Division (Presiding Justice Lee Heung-ku) overturned the lower court ruling that had ruled against courier company A in its lawsuit seeking to revoke a Central Labor Relations Commission decision on unfair labor practices, and sent the case back to the lower court.


Previously, the courier workers' union, a nationwide industry-level union, had demanded collective bargaining from company A, the principal courier headquarters, between March and May 2020, seeking improved working conditions. Approximately 1,200 delivery workers affiliated with agencies that had entered into subcontracting agreements with company A were members of the union.


However, company A refused the bargaining, stating, "We do not have a direct employment contract with agency delivery workers and are therefore not their employer." The union filed a complaint with the labor commission, claiming this constituted an unfair labor practice. The Seoul Regional Labor Relations Commission, which reviewed the case at first instance, sided with company A. However, on appeal, the Central Labor Relations Commission determined that company A had the status of an employer, as it could substantially and specifically control and determine the working conditions of the delivery workers, and therefore found that company A had a duty to bargain.


Both the first and second instance courts in the ensuing administrative lawsuit agreed with the Central Labor Relations Commission's decision and dismissed company A's claim. However, the Supreme Court reached a different conclusion. The key issue was whether, under the former Trade Union Act applicable at the time of the 2020 collective bargaining refusal, the principal contractor could be regarded as an employer.


The Supreme Court stated, "Under cases governed by the former Trade Union Act, the established legal principle is that an employer with a duty to engage in collective bargaining is one who has an explicit or implicit employment contract with the worker, including exercising direction and supervision and paying wages. This principle remains valid." This follows a precedent confirmed by the Supreme Court's full bench in May 2026.



The Supreme Court further explained the reason for overturning the lower court's decision: "Since there can be no explicit or implicit employment relationship between company A and the agency delivery workers, it is difficult to regard company A as an employer with a duty to engage in collective bargaining under the former Trade Union Act. The lower court erred in its interpretation of the legal principles regarding employers and collective bargaining duties under the former law."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing