Red Card Upheld, But Ban Suspended
FIFA Decision Sparks Fairness Debate, Global Backlash
Former FIFA President Blatter Joins the Criticism

The White House has countered the growing controversy over U.S. President Donald Trump’s alleged intervention in the process that effectively suspended the ban on U.S. national team’s star striker Folarin Balogun at the 2026 North and Central America World Cup, arguing that the core issue is not political pressure but rather "questionable refereeing decisions and procedural flaws."


On July 9, Yonhap News reported that Andrew Giuliani, Director of the White House World Cup Task Force, repeatedly emphasized during a briefing for foreign correspondents hosted by the U.S. State Department in Washington, D.C., the existence of "a referee involved in a match-fixing investigation" and that "procedures were improperly applied" in the process of Balogun's dismissal.

Andrew Giuliani, White House World Cup Task Force Director. Photo by AP Yonhap News

Andrew Giuliani, White House World Cup Task Force Director. Photo by AP Yonhap News

View original image

Director Giuliani commented on the Brazilian referee Raphael Claus issuing a red card to Balogun, saying, "We had very strong suspicions because there is a history of him being investigated in matters related to abnormal red cards." He further claimed, "The VAR procedure was also mishandled," adding, "In the case of contact fouls, decisions should not be made using slow-motion footage, but in this case, slow-motion was in fact used."


Balogun was sent off in the Round of 32 match against Bosnia and Herzegovina after VAR review deemed his stamp on opponent Tarik Muharemovic’s ankle as dangerous play. As a result, he was to be suspended for the Round of 16 match against Belgium, but FIFA’s Disciplinary Committee deferred the automatic one-match ban for one year. Although the red card itself was not rescinded, Balogun was permitted to play against Belgium. However, the United States was eliminated after losing 1-4 to Belgium.


Director Giuliani responded to a Brazilian journalist’s rebuttal that Claus was never investigated or prosecuted for match-fixing but only testified as a witness before the Brazilian parliament, stating, "That does not mean he was a criminal suspect," while also maintaining, "He was involved in a match-fixing investigation, and the issue of abnormal red cards was raised during that investigation. That is what matters."


In response to these statements, both FIFA and the Brazilian Football Confederation publicly defended referee Claus. FIFA described Claus as "one of the world’s top professional referees," stating that "a high level of professionalism and integrity has been demonstrated throughout his career." The Brazilian Football Confederation also stated, "There is no basis for doubting Claus’s credibility," and that "any insinuation or insult damaging his integrity is unacceptable."

President Trump Called FIFA President Infantino to Request a Review of the Ban

The controversy intensified after President Trump admitted that he directly requested FIFA President Gianni Infantino to reconsider Balogun’s ban. President Trump told reporters at the White House, "All I did was request a review," and "I did not instruct FIFA to do anything." He added, "I only learned after the match that a red card automatically leads to a ban for the next game," arguing, "There’s a difference between being punished during a match and being punished for a match that hasn’t even been played yet. That’s very unfair."

U.S. President Donald Trump. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

U.S. President Donald Trump. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

President Trump also claimed, "It wasn’t even a foul or a violation," explaining that he saw Balogun’s play as two players colliding at full speed. In separate remarks, he added, "I didn’t even know what a red card was. When I found out, I thought, ‘This must be a joke,’" further fueling the controversy.


President Infantino acknowledged the phone call with President Trump but emphasized, "FIFA’s judicial bodies operate independently and make decisions based on the relevant rules and facts." FIFA stated that, under Article 27 of its disciplinary regulations, execution of sanctions can be fully or partially suspended. However, critics are questioning the fact that the ban was suspended immediately after the public request by the host nation’s head of state during the World Cup knockout stage.

Strong Backlash After Ban Suspension

The backlash from the European football community was intense. UEFA described the decision as "incomprehensible and unjustifiable," criticizing FIFA for "crossing the red line." UEFA emphasized that "football stands on the certainty of its rules," and warned that "if the very institutions tasked with upholding those rules undermine that certainty, the integrity of the competition and the trust in the tournament are compromised."


The Belgian Football Association also contested Balogun’s eligibility to play against Belgium, but FIFA dismissed the objection. The Belgian side expressed "surprise," and it was reported that Belgium manager Rudi Garcia likened the decision to an April Fools’ joke. After defeating the United States 4-1, the Belgian team reportedly parodied President Trump’s ‘YMCA dance’ in the locker room, fueling interpretations that the controversy actually served to motivate the Belgian squad.

Balogun himself apologized to fans after the United States' elimination. He bowed his head, expressing that his first World Cup ended disappointingly and said, "We let you down." AP Yonhap News

Balogun himself apologized to fans after the United States' elimination. He bowed his head, expressing that his first World Cup ended disappointingly and said, "We let you down." AP Yonhap News

View original image

The controversy spread to the England national team as well. England defender Jarell Quansah was sent off in the 54th minute of the Round of 16 match against Mexico for a studs-up tackle on Jesus Gallardo following a VAR review. As a result, Quansah is unable to play in the quarterfinal match against Norway according to regulations, but given the Balogun precedent, the English Football Association is now considering an appeal or a possible deferral of the ban.


An England team spokesperson stated, "We are considering all possible options regarding Quansah’s red card." Some in the British political arena have also argued that the standards applied to Balogun should be equally applied to Quansah. British MPs Noah Rowe and Melanie On are reported to have sent a letter to FIFA requesting that Quansah’s ban be postponed until after the World Cup.


England manager Thomas Tuchel expressed concern that the suspension of Balogun’s ban could set a dangerous precedent. He questioned, "Who, when, and on what basis overturns these decisions?" and added, "Now, I don’t know where this starts or ends. We just want consistency in rulings." Tuchel also argued that Quansah’s sending-off itself "was not worthy of a red card."


Former FIFA President Sepp Blatter also joined the criticism. He stated, "A red card should not be overturned by a political phone call, but rather be determined by the rules, evidence, and independent bodies," and added, "If the U.S. President intervened with the FIFA President and a player suddenly became eligible to play right before a World Cup knockout match, we must question where FIFA is headed."



It was also reported that more than 70 Members of the European Parliament have called for an investigation into President Infantino and FIFA’s decision-making process. They argue that it must be clarified whether FIFA violated the principle of political neutrality and whether the host nation’s government influenced the disciplinary proceedings. After the U.S. defeat, Balogun himself apologized to fans, bowing his head and saying that his first World Cup ended in disappointment and "we disappointed you." However, the controversy over Balogun’s eligibility has not subsided even after the U.S. was eliminated.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing