In South Korea, Bar Association Advertising Rules Stand in the Way

A creditor who received assistance from the AI law firm Garfield AI has won a case in a UK court. This marks the first known instance in which a plaintiff supported by Garfield AI prevailed in court after UK authorities officially approved Garfield AI as a law firm specializing in small claims collection and related matters in 2025.

Example of a rebuttal document against an opposing response drafted by Garfield AI based on user input. Screenshot from Garfield AI YouTube.

Example of a rebuttal document against an opposing response drafted by Garfield AI based on user input. Screenshot from Garfield AI YouTube.

View original image

On June 22, Garfield AI announced on its website that a freelancer who used its services had won a court case. In its press release, the company stated, "This is the first time globally that a legal dispute has been won in court with the help of an AI lawyer." Garfield AI is a legal tech startup co-founded in 2023 by litigation attorney Philip Young and quantum physicist Daniel Long, and is headquartered in London.


Previously, on May 14, the Wandsworth County Court in London ruled in favor of the plaintiff, HR freelancer Tamires Kamal Taquidir, in a small claims case against a hospitality business. She had entered into a verbal agreement to provide HR services but was not paid 7,000 pounds (approximately 14.3 million won). In the UK, solicitors provide legal services before trial, while barristers handle courtroom advocacy. The plaintiff engaged Garfield AI for pre-trial legal work and hired barrister Dominic Lee for in-court advocacy. Both the defendant's solicitor and barrister were human lawyers. The plaintiff paid Garfield AI about 400 pounds (around 800,000 won).


On a podcast released on June 25, Taquidir said, "I didn't know any solicitors and had no idea how much time or cost would be involved. Garfield AI broke down the daunting legal process into manageable steps so that I could respond appropriately."


Barrister Lee wrote on social media, "The documents prepared by Garfield formed a solid foundation that enabled me to prepare for cross-examination and closing arguments." He added, however, "It was essential to test the evidence through cross-examination at the witness stand, and that was fundamentally a human task."


In the UK, consumers can use Garfield AI like a chatbot to access affordable legal services. According to a user guide video released in 2025, users can upload documents such as contracts or other debt-related paperwork to the chat window, or describe their situation. Garfield AI then requests any additional necessary information and, without human lawyer intervention, drafts pre-action letters, claims forms, and particulars of claim. When a response is received from the opposing party, Garfield AI analyzes it and works with the user to draft a rebuttal document.


In May 2025, the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) of England and Wales approved Garfield AI as a law firm providing legal services through artificial intelligence, citing its significant public benefit.


In South Korea, current law presents significant legal risks for law firms that allow legal consumers to directly use AI legal services. In fact, in 2024, the Korean Bar Association determined that law firm DaeryookAju and its attorneys violated the Attorney-at-Law Act by offering AI legal services and decided to impose disciplinary action. The Bar Association cited violations of Article 34(5) of the Attorney-at-Law Act, which prohibits non-lawyers from sharing fees or other benefits derived from work that only lawyers are permitted to do, as well as the Bar Association's regulations banning advertisements for free or unreasonably low-priced services. DaeryookAju objected and filed a petition with the Ministry of Justice in January 2025. A decision on the matter has not yet been made.



Baek Jinwoo, Legal Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing