The Paradox Hidden in Na Hongjin's "Hope"
A Name That Endures Through Repeated Despair

※ This article contains many potential spoilers for the movie.


A mysterious creature appears in a village near the Demilitarized Zone (DMZ). Police officers Beomseok (Hwang Jungmin) and Seongae (Jung Hoyeon) fight alongside villagers, including Seonggi (Jo Inseong), to confront it. However, the villagers are either killed or injured, and the village is left in ruins. The situation for the creature is equally grim. It loses its child, and the mothership sinks.


Director Na Hongjin.

Director Na Hongjin.

View original image

Judging by the plot alone, it is a complete tragedy. Yet the title is "Hope." On July 7, director Na Hongjin was asked, "Giving the name ‘Hope’ after painting a picture of catastrophe seems more like a post hoc naming than a narrative logic." He replied, "You're right. A title like 'Nothing Works Out' might be more fitting," and laughed.


The reason he insisted on the title "Hope" can be understood by looking into the perspective—meaning narrative style or viewpoint. His previous film "The Wailing" was set in a supernatural and folk-religious worldview, showing only as much as the characters doubted or believed. The audience’s gaze was confined by the characters’ beliefs. "Hope" breaks away from this approach. Director Na said, "I wanted to try a god's-eye perspective with more concise and daring explanations." In other words, he chose a viewpoint that observes the entire situation.


However, broadening the perspective did not mean shifting the center of empathy. Director Na revives the limited gaze of "The Wailing" in a different way, firmly anchoring the audience’s emotions on the human side. For the first 50 minutes, events are viewed solely through Beomseok’s eyes, forcing the audience to rely on his experience. After the creature appears, new pieces of information are provided. One is the testimony of the elderly Haesul (Im Hyunsik), who recounts his experience in a comical tone, eliciting laughter. The other is the truth behind the incident: a villager named Yangbae (Um Munseok) killed the creature’s child.


Still cut from the movie 'Hope'.

Still cut from the movie 'Hope'.

View original image

Director Na revealed, "I deliberately arranged it this way to instill a sense of guilt in the audience right after making them laugh." The design was meticulous, but he did not calculate the reception. "I didn’t scrutinize whether the guilt would actually be conveyed. It doesn’t matter if it’s not felt. It’s a metaphor, after all. The plot itself pretends as if nothing is wrong."


After the truth is revealed, another clash occurs between Seonggi and the creature. The audience knows who killed the creature’s child. In a typical creature invasion film, empathy would shift toward the invader. However, Director Na prevented this shift. "I wanted to create a paradoxical situation where, even after knowing the truth, the audience still sides with their own kind. I tilted the playing field this much, and I was curious how viewers would perceive and feel about it."


In this state of contradiction, the audience is confronted with over 40 minutes of spectacular action. Director Na described this part as "posing as an action movie, so the audience gets absorbed and forgets the tragedy." He added, "Even as I kept asking myself, 'Is this really all there is to say about the situation?', I wanted to let the audience fully immerse themselves in the action."


Movie still cut from "Hope".

Movie still cut from "Hope".

View original image

Room for guilt was left at the conclusion. Jor (Alicia Vikander), the mother of the deceased creature child, appears and expresses her despair. The film is structured to make the audience laugh, instill guilt, allow them to forget it through immersion, and then bring the guilt back at the end. Director Na stated, "Whether each stage actually works is a separate issue. The goal was the design itself, not the delivery." Nonetheless, he intentionally placed opportunities for empathy throughout the film, such as by depicting a pet-like companion that used to play with the deceased creature child in an endearing way.


He said, "Hope loses its function the moment it is realized." Neither the characters nor the creatures get what they want. At every moment, they hope, and at every moment, they are frustrated. Yet, as long as this cycle does not stop, hope does not disappear.


In the latter part of the film, the creature utters words reminiscent of Hebrews 11:1: "Faith is the evidence of things not seen." This refers not to faith proven by results, but to the act of holding on even when nothing can be seen. The sinking of the mothership and the child’s death are merely the stage where that faith is tested; they are not devices that deny hope.



Still cut from the movie 'Hope'.

Still cut from the movie 'Hope'.

View original image

If you accept this definition, the joke about the title being chosen because "nothing works out" becomes only half a joke. Because nothing has been achieved, hope, paradoxically, has not lost its function. The place where the name "Hope" endures is precisely there.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing