Reporting All General Property Crimes Could Delay Investigations
Alternative Proposal: Use Criteria from the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic or Specific Crimes
Police Request Response Within Five Days; Ministry of the Inter

The police have submitted their position to the government, stating that the scope of cognizable crimes that must be reported to the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA) should be significantly reduced. They are proposing to narrow the scope from all property-related crimes under the Criminal Act, which are broadly defined, to only major cases subject to harsher penalties under laws such as the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes.


According to a compilation of reports by The Asia Business Daily on July 7, the National Police Agency recently responded to the SCIA establishment support team, stating that it is difficult to accept the current draft of the SCIA Act enforcement decree. Instead, they suggested supplementing the law with provisions from statutes such as the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes and the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes, which set out aggravated sentencing standards. Under the current draft, the National Police Agency would have to report up to 580,000 cases annually to the SCIA, but with the proposed alternatives, this number would be reduced to tens of thousands.


Seodaemun-gu Police Agency, Seoul. Photo by Hyunmin Kim

Seodaemun-gu Police Agency, Seoul. Photo by Hyunmin Kim

View original image

The draft enforcement decree completed its public notice period as of July 6. The decree sets the criteria for serious crimes that investigative agencies, including the police, must mandatorily report to the SCIA. As long as a case falls under one of the six major crime categories—corruption, economic crimes, defense industry, narcotics, insurrection/foreign exchange, and cybercrime—the decree would require the police to report virtually all such cases. Exceptions, such as "where the content of a complaint or accusation is unclear or there is no investigative value," are only narrowly stipulated.


The most problematic area is economic crime. If the draft decree is enacted as is, the police would be required to report all crimes falling under fraud, embezzlement, or breach of trust according to the Criminal Act to the SCIA and wait for a reply regarding whether the case will be transferred. Even a fraud case involving only tens of thousands of won would be subject to mandatory reporting and thus unavoidable delays in investigation, simply because it is one of the six major crime categories. However, if the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes is applied, only cases where the value of property or benefits obtained through crimes such as fraud, embezzlement, or breach of trust exceeds 500 million won would be subject to reporting. For narcotics crimes, if the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes is applied, only cases involving narcotics valued at 5 million won or more would require notification, thereby reducing the reporting requirements.


Additionally, the police have expressed that crimes such as violations of the Act on the Compensation for Damage Caused by Communications Fraud, including voice phishing, should be excluded from mandatory reporting. Since the current government-wide response organization to communications financial fraud, led by the police, is already in operation, they argue that it would be more appropriate for the SCIA to join this system rather than duplicate efforts.


[Exclusive] Police Oppose 'SCIA Notification'... Propose Alternative Under Specific Economic Crimes Act View original image

The speed at which the SCIA responds to notifications about whether to take over a case is also a point of contention. The National Police Agency has proposed that the SCIA should decide on the transfer of cases within five days. In comparison, the Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials (CIO) currently responds within 60 days after being notified of crimes related to high-ranking officials by other investigative agencies, with possible extensions. The police argue that if the SCIA also takes up to 60 days to respond to serious crimes such as narcotics offenses with a high risk of suspects fleeing, this would lead to significant delays and hinder prompt initial investigative actions.


Hong Seokki, Commissioner General of the National Investigation Headquarters, pointed out at a meeting on July 6 that the current draft would impose a heavy burden on investigative agencies. He stated, "We are currently discussing the appropriate scope again after pointing out the problems and proposing remedies," adding, "We submitted our opinion to ensure that neither the speed nor the rigor of case transfers is compromised."


An official from the Ministry of the Interior and Safety said, "The police have indicated that if they are required to report cases that do not fall within the SCIA's investigative scope, it would result in unnecessary administrative workload, such as preparing and delivering documents." The official added, "We are also reviewing ways to set the response deadline for starting investigations as short as possible, to prevent it from taking up to a month or two."



Meanwhile, the CIO has also expressed opposition to the provision requiring notification of cognizable crimes. The CIO argues that if the decree is enacted as is, the SCIA, which is under the direction of the Minister of the Interior and Safety, would learn most information about crimes involving high-ranking officials, thereby potentially undermining the CIO's investigative independence. The CIO also pointed out that this could conflict with its priority investigative authority.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing