Won on Performance but Lost to NATO Unity... Korean Submarines Make Their Mark on the World Stage
Canada Submarine Bid Ends in Disappointment
Prime Minister Carney: "A Very Difficult Decision"
Unified Effort from Government, Hanwha, and HD Hyundai
Hanwha's Delivery Capability Stands Out
Fierce Competition with Germany, the Submarin
Hanwha Ocean fell short in its bid for Canada’s Next-Generation Submarine Project (CPSP). Despite forming a unified front with HD Hyundai Heavy Industries and the Korean government and engaging in fierce competition until the very end, they were not selected as the preferred negotiation partner. Industry insiders note that this high-profile bidding war against Germany, the world’s largest submarine powerhouse, significantly showcased Korea’s submarine-building capabilities to the global market.
On July 6 (local time), Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announced at the Halifax Naval Base that “Germany’s ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) has been chosen as the preferred negotiation partner.” Should negotiations between the Canadian government and TKMS fall through, Hanwha Ocean will enter negotiations as the next in line.
The Dosan Ahn Changho, the first domestically produced submarine to cross the Pacific, is seen at the Esquimalt Naval Base pier in Victoria, Canada. Photo by Yonhap News Agency
View original imageThe CPSP aims to replace the aging Victoria-class submarines by introducing up to 12 new diesel-powered submarines. When factoring in maintenance, repair, and operations (MRO) costs over 30 years, the total project value could reach up to 60 trillion won. Hanwha Ocean proposed an upgraded version of its domestically designed 3,000-ton Jangbogo-III submarine, while TKMS presented the 212CD model. Both models were evaluated as meeting the Canadian Navy’s operational performance requirements. Prime Minister Carney commented, “This was a very difficult and close decision made between two extremely qualified suppliers,” adding, “Both platforms met the very high capability standards required by the Royal Canadian Navy.” Ultimately, the outcome was decided by factors outside the submarines themselves.
Industry experts believe that Canada’s geopolitical position and the security cohesion among North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) member states were decisive factors, rather than product performance. Germany, as a NATO ally, emphasized interoperability. It also proposed that if Canada adopts the 212CD, Germany, Norway, and Canada jointly operate a fleet of 24 submarines in the Arctic and North Atlantic. For Canada, this option would allow 100% sharing of logistics and maintenance systems with allied nations, significantly reducing long-term MRO costs and strengthening control over Arctic security.
In terms of delivery schedule, Hanwha Ocean was seen as having the upper hand, with its production line already operational, while the 212CD remains at the design stage. To address this disadvantage, the German and Norwegian governments took the rare step of reallocating one unit each from their own navies’ orders for priority delivery to Canada. Financing conditions were another variable. Canada became the first non-European country to sign onto SAFE, the European defense industry’s joint procurement financial program, which provides financial support such as low-interest loans for the purchase of European-made weapons. This institutional backing at the European level, rather than individual company competitiveness, worked in Germany’s favor.
Hanwha Group built a collaborative network by signing memorandums of understanding (MOUs) with over 100 Canadian companies, organizations, and schools, involving affiliates such as Hanwha Ocean, Hanwha Aerospace, Hanwha Systems, and Hanwha Energy. According to KPMG analysis, Hanwha’s investment in Canada is projected to create more than 500,000 jobs and contribute a cumulative 120 billion Canadian dollars (about 130 trillion won) in gross domestic product (GDP) by 2044. Hanwha Ocean dispatched the 3,000-ton Dosan Ahn Changho submarine to Canada to directly demonstrate its performance and, unlike Germany—which only provided a scale model—presented a detailed MRO package price proposal.
HD Hyundai Heavy Industries also supported the bid as part of the unified team. President Joo Wonho and other executives visited Canada, met with major local shipbuilders such as Davie Shipbuilding and Irving Shipbuilding, and discussed joint naval ship projects and technology cooperation. They also proposed a long-term industrial cooperation package, including technology transfer, MRO, local workforce training, and joint research on AI-based autonomous navigation. Domestic defense companies including LIG Nex1, Hyundai Rotem, and Korea Aerospace Industries (KAI) also joined in, but it was not enough to overcome the cohesion among NATO allies.
Industry observers note that simply reaching the final stage against Germany, a leading company with over 100 years of conventional submarine technology, proves the competitiveness of Korean submarines. Moon Keunsik, a special professor at Hanyang University’s Graduate School of Public Policy, commented, “We won in terms of submarine performance, but ultimately lost due to the united political decision of NATO member states,” adding, “Demonstrating our capabilities in competition with the global leader will significantly aid exports to non-NATO countries.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
A Hanwha Ocean representative stated, “We will thoroughly analyze the lessons learned from this bidding process and devise solid alternatives,” emphasizing, “We are committed to finding a way for K-marine defense to advance further in the global market.” An HD Hyundai Heavy Industries representative said, “Although this did not result in a win, the experience of working as a unified team for Korea will serve as a strong stepping stone for K-defense to take another leap forward. We will do our utmost to expand K-defense exports and promote national interests in the future.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.