'Fivefold Damages and 1 Billion Won Fines' Instead of Criminal Penalties

The law punishing the spread of false information online, which had disappeared after being ruled unconstitutional by the Constitutional Court, has returned in a more sophisticated form after about 16 years. Although it does not directly regulate every citizen, concerns are mounting that the ambiguous standards for determining what is false, as well as indirect censorship through platforms, will chill freedom of expression. This is once again fueling social conflict.


[Why&Next]Revival of False Information Punishment Law Disappeared After the 'Minerva' Incident View original image

The amendment to the Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization and Information Protection, which imposes punitive damages and fines for fake news and similar content, is centered on holding media outlets and commercial YouTubers who intentionally distribute false or manipulated information liable for punitive damages of up to five times the actual damages. If the information is redistributed more than twice, a fine of up to 1 billion won will be imposed.


The "Minerva incident," which shook Korean society in 2009, is known as the starting point for sanctions against false and manipulated information. At that time, the administration under President Lee Myung-bak arrested and detained the netizen known as Minerva for "spreading false information with the intent to harm the public interest" after he criticized the government's foreign exchange policy. The law applied in this case was Article 47, Paragraph 1 of the Framework Act on Telecommunications, which stipulated imprisonment of up to five years or a fine of up to 50 million won. Prosecutors indicted Minerva and sought a prison sentence of one year and six months.


However, the court of first instance acquitted Minerva, ruling that it was difficult to conclude that he knowingly posted something completely false given the circumstances at the time, and that there was no intent to harm the public interest. After his release, Minerva filed a constitutional complaint, arguing that "the state arresting and punishing citizens under vague laws is contrary to the Constitution." The Constitutional Court accepted this argument, and the relevant legal provision was abolished.


The aim of the current amendment is also to prevent the harm caused to victims and to society by the distribution of false and manipulated information. It reflects the reality that fake news, which is highly profitable on social networking services (SNS) through view counts, has evolved into a form of crime. Currently, with advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) technology, deepfake videos and manipulated information that are difficult to distinguish from real content are being produced indiscriminately online.

[Why&Next]Revival of False Information Punishment Law Disappeared After the 'Minerva' Incident View original image

The government has taken a different approach from the past in punishing "fake news." While the state overtly used public authority to apply pressure during the Minerva case, the new amendment uses economic burdens to induce self-censorship. It allows victims to file civil lawsuits or platforms to voluntarily judge and remove content. Platforms such as Google and Naver are now more likely to proactively block posts that may be controversial. This is effectively censorship without direct government intervention.


However, not only opposition parties but also civil society are voicing opposition, arguing that the new amendment infringes on freedom of expression. A National Assembly petition calling for the withdrawal of the amendment garnered 140,000 signatures in just one month. Progressive organizations such as the People's Solidarity for Participatory Democracy and Lawyers for a Democratic Society have also expressed concern about the implementation of the amendment.


The Journalists Association of Korea issued a statement the previous day, saying, "If media organizations are repeatedly exposed to massive damages claims and legal disputes, the chilling effect is inevitable," and demanded, "Effective protective measures must be in place so that journalism in the public interest is not undermined."



The Korea Communications Commission addressed concerns about "government-led online pre-censorship," explaining, "The amended Information and Communications Network Act stipulates that whether information constitutes false or manipulated content should be determined by large information and communications service providers according to their own policies." The commission added, "We have also established procedural safeguards, such as excluding public interest reporting from punitive damages, to ensure that freedom of the press and expression are not undermined."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing