Overturning the Three-Month Sentence: Acquitted on Appeal
Appellate Court Rules, "A Simple Mistake Caused by Exhaustion"

An employee at a convenience store in Taiwan was prosecuted for occupational embezzlement after forgetting to pay for a cup of coffee during an overnight shift. However, the appellate court acquitted the employee, ruling that it was a simple mistake caused by exhaustion. The court also strongly criticized the owner for pursuing criminal charges.


According to the Taiwanese media outlet United Daily News (UDN) on July 5 (local time), the Taiwan High Court found the convenience store employee, referred to as Mr. A, not guilty of occupational embezzlement. The judges rebuked the store owner, stating, "The owner enjoys the economic benefits of 24-hour business operations but filed criminal charges against an employee for a mistake."


Judge's gavel. Pixabay

Judge's gavel. Pixabay

View original image

The incident occurred in May of last year. At her boyfriend's request, Mr. A covered a late-night shift at a convenience store franchise in Beitou, Taiwan, without receiving any wages.


According to prosecutors, Mr. A had worked from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. the previous day and immediately started the overnight shift. Around 4 a.m. the next morning, she made herself an oat milk latte worth 75 New Taiwan Dollars (approximately 3,600 won) but did not pay for it. The store manager checked the CCTV footage and reported the matter to the police. Prosecutors then charged Mr. A with occupational embezzlement.


Mr. A argued that she had simply forgotten to pay due to extreme fatigue. However, the court of first instance did not accept this defense and sentenced her to three months in prison, which could be commuted to a fine.


The appeals court reached a different conclusion, determining that she had no intention of unlawfully acquiring property. The ruling cited as evidence that Mr. A had prepaid for 32 oat milk lattes before the incident, with 26 remaining at the time. It was also confirmed that she properly paid for a beverage at 6 a.m. on the same day.


The judges noted that it is entirely plausible for an employee to delay payment and forget after drinking a beverage to maintain energy during a shift. The fact that Mr. A made and drank the coffee in front of the surveillance camera was also cited as evidence of a lack of intent.


Mr. A presented additional arguments during the appeal, stating that she also received a demand from the manager to compensate 15,000 New Taiwan Dollars (about 720,000 won) because her fatigue led to delays in stocking fresh food. She further claimed she was not paid for covering the shift and argued that the criminal complaint was an abuse of criminal procedure to resolve a civil dispute.


The court characterized the incident as a simple work error resulting from a missed payment. It pointed out that the matter should have been handled through labor law or internal regulations, rather than criminal prosecution. The judges criticized the use of national judicial resources as a means of intimidating employees in business management.


The prosecutors also faced criticism. The court stated that a focus solely on prosecution and guilty verdicts does not contribute to the rational allocation of judicial resources. The judges also pointed out that the court of first instance failed to adequately consider the general principle that extreme fatigue can temporarily impair attention and memory.



The judges emphasized, "The law is an art for goodness and justice," adding, "Rigid application of the law must not take precedence over empathy and substantive justice for overworked employees."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing