Hanwha Ocean and Germany's TKMS Face Off
Shipbuilding Fundamentals Remain Strong Amid Conservative Expectations

On May 24th, Canadian Navy personnel at the Esquimalt base in Victoria, Canada, welcomed the crew members of the domestically produced submarine Dosan Ahn Changho (SS-III, 3,000-ton class) as it arrived. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

On May 24th, Canadian Navy personnel at the Esquimalt base in Victoria, Canada, welcomed the crew members of the domestically produced submarine Dosan Ahn Changho (SS-III, 3,000-ton class) as it arrived. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Investor interest in shipbuilding stocks is rising over Hanwha Ocean's bid for the Canadian submarine project. Although the total size of the deal is an unprecedented 60 trillion won, many expect that even if Hanwha Ocean does not win the bid, the negative impact will be limited. This is because expectations are already low and the share price is discounted, while shipbuilding industry indicators such as order intake and vessel prices are showing strong performance.


On July 7th, Samsung Securities analyzed that investors need not be overly swayed by the Canadian Patrol Submarine Project (CPSP). Canada’s project aims to procure twelve 3,000-ton class submarines, with a total project value reported to be 60 trillion won. Hanwha Ocean is competing against Germany’s Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) for the contract.


Korea’s advantages are clear. It can deliver a proven submarine model already in operation at a relatively early stage. Security incidents involving the German company are also a variable that works in Korea’s favor. Hanwha Ocean’s proposal is to deliver four initial submarines by 2035, and then supply one vessel annually thereafter.


However, defense contracts are not decided solely on performance and price. Other variables such as security, diplomacy, joint operation, and contributions to the local industry also play a role. Germany, being a member of NATO, holds an advantage. Recently, Germany and Norway reportedly proposed a joint submarine operation strategy to Canada, even offering to give up Norway’s existing delivery slot and move up the initial supply timeline. As a result, the delivery timeline difference between Korea and Germany is now only about one year.


For this reason, it is difficult to predict the probability of winning the contract. However, the impact on the share price is different. Han Youngsoo, Head of the Industrial Research Team at Samsung Securities Research Center, stated, “Most investors we have recently met are conservative rather than optimistic in their outlook,” explaining that this is due to the cautious remarks from Korean government officials and news that Germany could leverage support from all of Europe.


If Hanwha Ocean wins the order, it would serve as an upward driver for the stock price. However, even if it fails, the impact is expected to be temporary and not severe. This is because the company is already trading at a deeply discounted valuation within the industrial sector. Notably, even Hanwha Ocean, which once enjoyed a defense premium, is now trading at a valuation similar to its shipbuilding competitors. Some investors are even interpreting the Canadian submarine project itself as a source of uncertainty.



What is more important is the core business. Shipbuilding market indicators remain strong. The newbuilding price index stayed at 185, the same as the previous week. The secondhand ship price index rose by one point. The Clarkson Index, which reflects vessel profitability, was $37,543 per day, up 0.8% from the previous week. Although tanker indicators were weak, this was offset by strength in bulk carriers and container ships. Global ship orders in the first half of the year also increased by 88% compared to the previous year. This means that, regardless of the Canadian submarine project, the fundamentals of the shipbuilding industry remain sound.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing