Jeju Nonghyup Chief Shouts "Diesel OOO Won!" Association Responds "Sounds Good"... Jeju Nonghyup and Gas Station Association Hit with 2 Billion Won Fine for Fuel Price Cartel
First-Ever Heavy Fines for 'Prohibited Collective Actions' in the Gas Station Sector
Price Information Shared Before Opinet Disclosure, Standard Price Set
Meticulous Cover-Up: Encouraging KakaoTalk Message Deletion to Dodge Regulatory Scrutiny
Jeju City Nonghyup and Seogwipo Nonghyup, which have operated highly price-competitive budget gas stations in Jeju, were caught by the Fair Trade Commission for colluding with the Korea Gas Station Association—a coalition of regular gas stations—to fix fuel prices in a classic 'price cartel.' This marks the first case in the gas station sector where individual gas stations (Nonghyup branches) involved in a business association's price-fixing activity have been hit with heavy fines for participating in prohibited collective actions.
Notification of Standard Fuel Prices for Gas Stations by Jeju Branch of the Korea Petroleum Association. Fair Trade Commission.
View original imageThe Gwangju Regional Office of the Fair Trade Commission announced on July 6 that it has decided to issue corrective orders and impose a total fine of 2.05 billion won on the Jeju Branch of the Korea Gas Station Association (Jeju Gas Station Association), Jeju City Agricultural Cooperative (Jeju Nonghyup), and Seogwipo Agricultural Cooperative (Seogwipo Nonghyup) for engaging in business association prohibited acts and actively participating in price controls. Specifically, the association was fined 30 million won, Jeju Nonghyup 987 million won, and Seogwipo Nonghyup 1.033 billion won. The Jeju Gas Station Association is an organization with 116 member gas stations in Jeju. Jeju Nonghyup operates three gas stations, while Seogwipo Nonghyup runs two, all five of which are members of the association.
"Diesel Price Up by 140 Won"—Profiteering Targeting Inelastic Demand from Rental Car Tourists
Nonghyup gas stations in Jeju enjoyed a clear price advantage over regular gas stations by leveraging bulk purchases through the Nonghyup Economic Holdings' large-scale procurement system. Regular stations, unable to sell fuel if priced higher than Nonghyup, needed advance notice of Nonghyup's prices, while Nonghyup sought to prevent any gas station from undercutting them and sparking a price war. The closed market structure of geographically isolated Jeju, combined with a high proportion of rental car tourists relatively insensitive to prices due to lack of public transportation, further emboldened these players to extract high margins.
Their collusion was meticulously divided. Before publicly releasing the next day’s fuel prices (gasoline, diesel, kerosene) on Opinet, the official oil price information service, Jeju Nonghyup and Seogwipo Nonghyup would secretly pass the information to the association. According to phone recordings secured by the Fair Trade Commission, the head of Jeju Nonghyup was heard shouting, "Diesel up by 140 won!" to which the association replied, "Sounds good," fully accepting the price hike request.
The association would then set the 'standard price' based on this information and issue instructions in anonymous KakaoTalk group chats for Jeju City (62 times) and Seogwipo City (60 times), stating, "There will be a price change from tomorrow. Please change it in the morning if possible."
"Fair Trade Commission Is Watching, Please Delete KakaoTalk Messages"... Caught Despite Meticulous Cover-Up
Their methods to avoid regulatory scrutiny were highly calculated. Fully aware that price notifications were illegal, the association repeatedly stressed in the chat rooms, "Please confirm and delete," and "Absolutely no external leaks." Particularly after the Fair Trade Commission launched a full investigation into LPG collusion in September 2023, the association announced, "The Fair Trade Commission is monitoring, so we will post notices without specific amounts. Please contact the association for details," switching from group chat notifications to more discreet methods such as phone calls or in-person visits to evade the investigation.
Nonghyup even took on the role of watchdog. If managers at Nonghyup gas stations discovered a nearby independent station selling fuel below the standard price, they immediately alerted the association, saying, "The station right next to us is selling at 1,610 won—what are we supposed to do? We’ll have to lower our price." The association would then visit the station in person, pressuring them to raise prices to comply with the standard. This cartel system only came to a complete halt when the Fair Trade Commission’s Gwangju office launched an on-site investigation on July 10, 2024.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Hyuncheol, head of the Fair Trade Commission’s Gwangju office, emphasized, "Even excluding the geographic disadvantages of island logistics, if this collusion had not occurred, Jeju residents and tourists could have purchased fuel for at least 10 won, and up to more than 60 won, less per liter. We will continue to rigorously monitor and take strict action against collusion that directly impacts people's daily lives."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.