Collusion with Spun-Off Affiliate in Security Service Bids
S-1 Corporation Won 21 Out of 23 Tenders Over Two Years

S-1 Corporation, a leading domestic security company, has been sanctioned by the Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) after using a former affiliate, which had previously spun off from S-1, as a proxy in order to sweep up integrated security service contracts for apartment complexes in non-metropolitan areas.

S-1 Fined 973 Million Won for Collusive Bidding with Proxy in Apartment Security Contracts View original image

On July 5, the KFTC announced its decision to impose corrective orders and a total fine of 973 million won on S-1 Corporation and S-Tech System Co., Ltd. The two companies had colluded to pre-select the winning bidder and fix the bidding price for integrated security service contracts at 23 private apartment complexes in six regions, including Busan, Gwangju, Daejeon, and Sejong. By company, S-1 Corporation was fined 641 million won, and S-Tech System Co., Ltd. was fined 332 million won.


According to the KFTC's investigation, S-1 Corporation was the likely winner based on its strong brand recognition and prior business activities. However, due to the small number of participants in local bids, the company was concerned that the lack of competition would result in failed tenders. To address this, S-1 Corporation asked S-Tech System Co., Ltd.—a company that had spun off from S-1 and maintained a long-standing partnership—to participate in the bidding as a placeholder.


During this process, S-1 Corporation employees even prepared bid calculation sheets, including the bidding price, on behalf of S-Tech System Co., Ltd. S-Tech System Co., Ltd. then submitted bids using the exact amounts provided, thus executing the collusion agreement.


Through this scheme, S-1 Corporation won or secured contracts through private negotiation in 21 out of 23 bids conducted from November 2022 to January 2025, effectively monopolizing the volume of contracts.



The KFTC stated, "This action is significant as it detected and penalized collusion in integrated security service bidding, which uses funds from apartment residents' management fees," adding, "We expect this will help curb similar collusive practices in the future and contribute to reducing apartment management fees."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing