Repair Costs Paid Minus Deductible
Full Subrogation Amount Settled Between Insurers
Supreme Court: "Driver’s Right to Claim Remains Valid"

Even if a driver’s own insurance company has already received reimbursement from the other party’s insurer—including the driver’s deductible—the driver can still separately claim any uncompensated deductible from the other party’s insurance company, according to a recent Supreme Court ruling. The decision states that any miscalculated amounts should be resolved between the insurers themselves.

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

On July 5, the legal community reported that the First Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Kwon Youngjun) recently overturned the lower court’s decision, which had ruled against the plaintiff, Mr. Park, who had filed a damages lawsuit against Hyundai Marine & Fire Insurance. The case has been sent back to Daejeon District Court for retrial.


After his car was damaged in a traffic accident, Mr. Park received compensation of about 2.2 million won for repair costs from his own insurer, except for a 500,000 won deductible. Later, Mr. Park’s insurance company claimed reimbursement from the other party’s insurer, Hyundai Marine & Fire Insurance, including the deductible that Mr. Park paid. The other insurer paid a total of about 1.08 million won, corresponding to the percentage of fault assigned to the other party. Mr. Park then filed a lawsuit against Hyundai Marine & Fire Insurance, seeking the return of the part of the deductible he had not recovered.


Both the first and second trials dismissed Mr. Park’s claim, stating that he had agreed by contract to bear the deductible himself.


However, the Supreme Court overturned the lower court’s decision, citing a precedent set by the Supreme Court’s full bench earlier this year. The Court clarified that an insurer can only exercise subrogation rights (insurer’s subrogation) within the scope of actual insurance payments made, and thus, cannot claim subrogation for the deductible amount that has not been paid out by the insurer.



The court stated, “Even if the other party’s insurance company has already paid an amount equivalent to the deductible to Mr. Park’s insurer, Mr. Park’s right to claim remains valid unless he specifically authorized the insurer to receive it on his behalf. Any excessive payment by the other insurer can be resolved by seeking restitution for unjust enrichment from Mr. Park’s insurer. However, Hyundai Marine & Fire Insurance must pay Mr. Park the deductible amount proportional to the percentage of fault.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing