[Exclusive] Sleeping with Nvidia, the K-Semiconductor Dilemma... Closed Networks and NDAs Activated [The Two Faces of Digital Twin] ①
Samsung and SK hynix Accelerate Toward Autonomous Factories with Nvidia Technology
Concerns Over Process Data and Know-How Exposure Persist Despite 'Closed Networks and NDAs'
"Failure to Achieve Technological Independence Could Undermine the Industrial Foundation"
K-Semiconductors have found themselves in a dilemma. To enhance manufacturing competitiveness, adopting the Nvidia platform is inevitable, but this process risks exposing data accumulated over decades of process know-how to external platforms. It has been confirmed that Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, as they introduce Nvidia’s core platforms into their semiconductor manufacturing processes, are implementing dual layers of protection against technology leaks, such as building closed networks and signing non-disclosure agreements (NDAs). However, experts warn that the defensive measures of individual companies alone are insufficient to protect process data, which is directly tied to national security. Since there are structural vulnerabilities that allow data to be accessed at any time under U.S. law, there is an urgent need for national-level infrastructure and policy strategies to secure sovereignty over industrial data.
The Two Giants of Memory Accelerate Transition to AI Factories
According to the semiconductor industry as of July 6, Samsung Electronics and SK hynix are shifting toward running the entire semiconductor production process—including design, operation, and improvement—on Nvidia technology. Instead of merely automating facilities, they are adopting artificial intelligence (AI) and digital twin technology at every stage of process design, operation, and optimization, thereby reshaping the manufacturing paradigm.
The key tool is the digital twin. This technology replicates an actual factory in a three-dimensional virtual space and runs processes in advance to find optimal conditions. Samsung Electronics has implemented digital twins for key production facilities, such as the Pyeongtaek Plant 1, using Nvidia’s virtual simulation platform Omniverse. This enables real-time analysis of equipment status and enhances an integrated monitoring system for detecting anomalies. In the photolithography process, which etches semiconductor circuits onto wafers, the company has adopted Nvidia’s computational program cuLitho to improve design accuracy and shorten development times. There are also plans to expand digital twins to overseas production bases, such as the plant in Taylor, United States.
SK hynix has also begun building digital twins for its factories using Omniverse, having completed related proof-of-concept (PoC) testing last year. By leveraging Nvidia’s development tools CUDA-X and PhysicsNeMo, the company is boosting the speed of design and manufacturing simulations. The goal is to create an autonomous fab, where the factory learns and makes decisions without human intervention, by 2030.
The Paradox of Cost-Efficiency... Structure of 'Voluntary Dependency'
The problem is that once companies enter the ecosystem, it is difficult to exit. Nvidia offers a full package for smart factories, from graphics processing units (GPUs) to simulation platforms and AI development tools. As soon as a company adopts this package, the factory’s data formats and work processes are all aligned with Nvidia’s standards. It then becomes the cheapest and fastest choice to handle new equipment installations or process changes within the already established Nvidia environment. Switching to another company’s platform would incur massive costs and carries the risk of production halts during the transition.
Nvidia has succeeded with this approach before. In the field of AI development, the use of GPUs inevitably led to the adoption of Nvidia’s CUDA development tools, a structure that has become entrenched over the years, making CUDA the de facto global standard for AI development. If the same strategy is applied to manufacturing, there are concerns that companies chasing performance may end up in a state of voluntary dependency on Nvidia.
Kim Myoungjoo, Professor at the Department of Information Security at Seoul Women’s University and Director of the Artificial Intelligence Safety Research Institute, stated, “Nvidia is pursuing the same strategy in the digital twin and physical AI domains as it did when it monopolized GPUs in the past. Domestic companies are aware of the risks, but their options are limited because there is currently no alternative technology or platform as sophisticated as Nvidia’s.”
Closed Networks and NDAs in Place... "Still No Guarantee of Safety"
Of course, companies are not standing idle. Samsung Electronics operates Omniverse-based digital twin services within a physically separated, closed private network and signs NDAs at the contract stage with platform suppliers. SK hynix completely separates and manages core process data from external frameworks, runs core solutions such as production, logistics, and physical simulations on its own platform, and uses Omniverse only as a subordinate tool for digital twin implementation. The intent is to fundamentally block the possibility of core technology leaks even while adopting external platforms.
However, experts commonly diagnose that such measures alone cannot guarantee safety. When digital twin and physical AI are combined, AI shifts to a structure where it learns in real time based on on-site data. In this process, on-site data—including process know-how—can be learned in reverse by external platforms. This means that the manufacturing competitiveness of K-Semiconductors, built up over decades, could leak out via these platforms.
Moon Songcheon, Professor Emeritus at KAIST Graduate School of Business, said, “There is a tendency to judge that it is safe just by inserting data leak prevention clauses in contracts and building on-premises (closed) servers on-site, but it should not be overlooked that software providers can access the data at any time if they choose to. The core technologies of the software engines, operating systems (OS), database management systems (DBMS), and network communication protocols running on closed servers are still controlled by big tech companies.”
There are also legal loopholes. Choi Byungho, Professor at the Korea University AI Research Institute, pointed out, “Regardless of whether terms and NDAs are in place, if the cloud location required for platform integration is in the United States, U.S. authorities can access the data.” Under the U.S. CLOUD Act, data stored on U.S.-based clouds can be accessed by law in the event of national security incidents or requests from the U.S. government. Professor Choi suggested, “Much like Google announced it would build a data center in Korea to protect data sovereignty, there needs to be a sophisticated negotiation with Nvidia as well, such as locating data centers domestically and encrypting data.”
Professor Kim further advised, “If information from real-world sensors or cameras is indiscriminately linked while building digital twins, unnecessary corporate know-how could be exposed externally. It is crucial to use data minimization techniques so that only essential information is selected for AI training and to stipulate in the contract that certain data is excluded from training during negotiations.”
"National Governance Beyond Corporate Defense Is Urgent"
In the long term, establishing national-level governance is seen as a key challenge. Only a select few companies, such as Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, have the capacity to build their own security infrastructure. Most medium-sized and small manufacturers are joining the global platform ecosystem without any dedicated data protection systems.
Professor Kim emphasized, “Most companies prioritize short-term profits and cannot foresee the risks of dependency 10 to 30 years down the line. The state must take on a governance role by monitoring the industrial ecosystem over the mid to long term and setting R&D alternatives.” Professor Moon also warned, “During the semiconductor supercycle, the seriousness of dependency is masked, but in the long run, if we fail to achieve self-sufficiency in core software technology, the industrial foundation itself could be shaken after the supercycle ends.”
A senior executive in the semiconductor industry also stated, “Design, process, and production data are the core assets of the semiconductor industry. There is an urgent need for government-level institutional and technological support, including expansion of domestic AI computing infrastructure and data centers, establishment of secure data sharing systems, and support for security technologies that comply with international standards.”
Possible strategies include localization of world models and building a national physical AI ecosystem. A world model is an AI that comprehensively learns the principles and rules by which the real world operates. With such a model, it is possible to create virtual environments—such as actual factories or roads—and simulate any operation in advance. Professor Choi explained, “The advancement of world models requires vast amounts of data and sophisticated manufacturing technology. The United States has not been able to achieve unilateral dominance in this field due to a lack of local manufacturing infrastructure and productivity. Korea’s world-class manufacturing technology and process data can become a powerful weapon.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.