Noah Bakery Seongsu Branch Interior Construction Fees Unpaid for Three Years... Counter-Lawsuit Over Liquidated Damages
Delayed Payment of 185 Million Won in Construction Fees Leads to Lawsuit
Noah Claims "Overpayment" After Amending Lawsuit Grounds
Interior Firm Files Criminal Complaint Against Noah CEO Noh Kyungbo for Fraud
Counterclaim to Be Filed With Co
For over a month, solo protests have been taking place in front of Noah Bakery's Seongsu and Apgujeong branches, which sell bread made with natural yeast.
The person behind these daily protests, which occur alternately at both locations from around 9 a.m. until after 9 p.m., is Mr. Park, an executive at Kraft J (CEO Choi Byungseok), an interior design company.
The placard he holds contains an appeal to Noah F&B (CEO Noh Kyungbo, hereafter referred to as "Noah"), the operator of Noah Bakery, demanding the return of 232 million won for interior construction work completed three years ago.
On the 3rd of last month, Mr. Park, an executive of Kraft J, held a solo protest in front of Noah Bakery Apgujeong Branch in Sinsa-dong, Gangnam-gu, Seoul. Photo by Seokjin Choi
View original imageResponsible for Seongsu Branch Interior Construction
At the end of 2022, Choi Byungseok, CEO of Kraft J, who had maintained a business relationship with Manager Kim of Noah for over 10 years, was asked to take on the interior construction work for the new Noah Bakery Seongsu Branch (from basement level 1 to the fourth floor) opening in Seongdong-gu, Seoul.
However, while discussing the scope of the project, it became necessary to relocate the main factory, previously located in the Apgujeong branch basement, to the Seongsu branch. This required major renovation work (construction to repair, alter, expand, or dismantle the structure or exterior of the building) for the installation of elevators and basement machinery.
Manager Kim, citing budget constraints, wanted CEO Choi to handle the entire project. However, CEO Choi did not have the general contractor license required for major renovation work and declined the request. In response, Manager Kim proposed that if CEO Choi could introduce a construction company that would handle the renovations for the lowest possible cost, he would award the interior project to Kraft J.
As a result, Channuri General Construction was introduced by CEO Choi to take charge of the major renovations, and CEO Choi proceeded with the interior work following the completion of those renovations. The interior construction contract between Kraft J and Noah was made verbally, with Noah approving the estimate provided by CEO Choi, rather than through a separate written contract. Meanwhile, a written contract for the renovation work was concluded with Channuri, which began the project in June 2022 and completed it in November of the same year.
Delays Due to Additional and Changed Requests
Problems emerged from the beginning of the construction. Noah, with no prior experience in major renovations, attempted to proceed without securing a demolition permit. It was only discovered later, and it took considerable time to obtain the permit with the building owner's consent. As a result, the demolition permit was granted three months after the scheduled start date, and the original completion date of November 2022 was postponed to February 2023, necessitating a new construction contract.
During the renovation, serious safety issues stemming from the building's age were discovered, requiring various additional works such as jack support reinforcement. In the course of the interior work performed by CEO Choi, Noah requested over ten additional or altered tasks, including ▲installation of a transformer for increased electrical capacity ▲expansion of the wastewater system ▲installation of an electric water heater ▲separate work on the building's exterior Dryvit finishing, and more. Ultimately, the usage permit was not granted until June 26, 2023, about eight months after the revised completion date.
With each new construction task, the project duration inevitably increased, but Channuri and Kraft J shared daily construction reports with Noah and obtained their approval at every stage.
A KakaoTalk conversation screenshot between Choi Byungseok, CEO of Kraft J, and Kim, Manager at Noah F&B, in October 2024. Manager Kim explains the company's difficult situation and the delayed payment. CEO Choi Byungseok
View original imageDelaying Payment, Then Suddenly Filing a Lawsuit
Even during the construction period, Noah frequently cited cash flow difficulties and failed to make timely payments for the work. After the interior work was finished, Noah continued to delay payment for various reasons. Later on, Channuri, the general contractor for the renovation, even proposed that CEO Choi assist with a lawsuit to recover delay damages, which would be used to pay the overdue interior fees.
Then, in July 2024, Noah abruptly filed a lawsuit against Channuri, seeking over 122 million won in delay damages and interest, and named Kraft J as a co-defendant. Not only did they seek joint liability for the renovation delays, but they also added about 55 million won in separate delay damages for the interior work, demanding a total of around 177 million won from both companies.
Noah's claim that Kraft J should share liability for the renovation delay with the general contractor is based on the fact that CEO Choi signed the construction contract as a "commissioned company" at Noah's request.
Although CEO Choi introduced the contractor for Noah's convenience and was formally listed as the policyholder in the performance bond contract, it was clear to all parties that Channuri was the main contractor for the renovation. Nevertheless, Noah is now holding CEO Choi responsible for the delay damages. This fact is clearly supported by KakaoTalk conversations and recorded phone calls between CEO Choi and Manager Kim.
Furthermore, last month Noah submitted an amendment to the complaint to the court, now claiming that Kraft J, not Channuri, was the party to the renovation contract, and alleging that more than 600 million won was overpaid for the renovation and interior works. Initially, when filing the delay damages lawsuit, Noah acknowledged the unpaid interior construction fees owed to CEO Choi. However, they are now making the absurd claim that there are construction costs to be reclaimed instead.
On the 28th of last month, Park Mo, an executive at Kraft J, was holding a solo protest in front of Noah Bakery Seongsu Branch in Seongsu-dong, Seongdong-gu, Seoul. Kraft J
View original imageCounterclaim and Criminal Complaint
As payment for the interior work has been delayed for a third year, several subcontractors involved in the project have faced severe financial distress. In May 2023, there was even a suicide attempt by Mr. Shim, a paint supervisor, who was not paid 12 million won for his work. The company that supervised the renovation work also has yet to receive a remaining balance of 10 million won.
Ultimately, in May, CEO Choi filed a criminal complaint against Noah CEO Noh Kyungbo for fraud with the Seoul Central District Prosecutors' Office. The case is currently under investigation at the Seongdong Police Station in Seoul. Other firms that participated in the interior construction but have not been paid are also preparing petitions and criminal complaints with the Seoul Regional Employment and Labor Office.
On the 3rd, CEO Choi plans to file a counterclaim with the Seoul Eastern District Court, demanding payment of over 185 million won in outstanding construction fees and approximately three years of interest.
CEO Choi stated, "For over 10 years, I have dedicated myself to Noah, handling not only the required interior work but also unrelated tasks, including renovations at the manager's home and moving bakery equipment. Despite all this, I am deeply frustrated and resentful after being kept waiting for three years, only to have them exploit my vulnerabilities and refuse to pay."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Meanwhile, Manager Kim of Noah commented, "This is not simply a matter of unilaterally delaying payment. Rather, the case has dragged on because the court dates in the lawsuit have been repeatedly postponed. The specific facts and allocation of responsibility will ultimately be determined by the court."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.