"Failure to Conduct Necessary Review Affected the Judgment"

The Supreme Court has ruled that a sentence handed down without considering the circumstances of a separate trial must be re-examined and determined again.

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On July 3, according to the legal community, the Supreme Court's Second Division (Presiding Justice Eom Sangpil) overturned the appellate court's sentence of two years and six months in prison against Mr. A, who was indicted on charges of violating the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes (breach of trust), and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court for retrial.


Mr. A, who served as CEO of a real estate sales and distribution agency in Yeonsu-gu, Incheon, was brought to trial on charges of causing losses amounting to a total of 1.7 billion won to victims between 2018 and 2020 by entering into sales contracts, receiving payments, but failing to transfer ownership registration as promised.


Both the first and second instance courts found Mr. A guilty of all charges. At the time, the court determined that Mr. A's case, in which he was sentenced to four years in prison by the Incheon District Court in August 2024 for another breach of trust, constituted a concurrent offense under the latter part of Article 37 of the Criminal Act together with the crimes in the present case. Since the crime in this case was committed before the former conviction was finalized, the court believed that fairness should be considered as if both cases were tried together. Accordingly, the appellate court applied the sentencing reduction provisions for concurrent offenses under the Criminal Act and sentenced Mr. A to two years and six months in prison.


However, the Supreme Court did not accept this. It found that there was a procedural flaw in the sentencing process, as it was discovered that before the prosecution in this case, Mr. A had already been indicted for a separate fraud case at the Incheon District Court, but this was omitted from consideration during sentencing.


According to Article 37 of the Criminal Act, if a crime is in a concurrent relationship with another crime for which a final judgment has been rendered, the sentence must be determined with fairness as if the cases were tried together.


The Supreme Court stated, "If a sentence of imprisonment or more has been finalized in the separate case as well, the present crime also constitutes a concurrent offense with that finalized crime," and further added, "The appellate court should have reviewed whether a judgment in the separate case had been rendered and finalized, and then determined the final sentence considering fairness as if the cases were tried together."



It continued, "By dismissing Mr. A's appeal without taking these steps, the appellate court misunderstood the relevant legal principles or failed to conduct necessary proceedings, which affected the outcome of the judgment."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing