Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Homeplus situation is reaching its final stage. On July 3, the Seoul Bankruptcy Court will decide whether to approve Homeplus's rehabilitation plan. If the court does not grant approval, Homeplus will enter the process of bankruptcy. However, there remains the option to extend the deadline for approval of the rehabilitation plan until September 4.


However, simply granting more time does not mean a solution will emerge. The central issue in Homeplus's rehabilitation is securing 200 billion won in emergency operating funds. Meritz Financial Group has left open the possibility of providing 100 billion won, but has made it conditional on MBK Partners' guarantee and additional funding. MBK has countered by arguing that it has already supplied a significant amount of funds and, therefore, it is Meritz that needs to make further concessions.


To be objective, the Homeplus situation is fundamentally about "who will bear the cost of rehabilitation." For employees, partners, tenants, and the local community, rehabilitation is the optimal outcome. However, MBK and Meritz have different calculations. From MBK's perspective, Homeplus is already a failed investment. With little possibility of recovering the equity value, injecting additional funds or providing guarantees would only increase losses rather than reduce them. If MBK has recouped losses elsewhere, it may be more rational to write off Homeplus as a failed deal. The situation is not much different for Meritz. Rehabilitation will take a long time, and it remains uncertain whether operations can return to normal. In contrast, liquidation may involve significant social costs, but for creditors, it provides a clearer picture of the extent of their losses.


Nevertheless, neither side can openly state that they want bankruptcy. Homeplus is intertwined with countless workers and partner companies. If the outcome is bankruptcy, public criticism will be unavoidable. This is why the dispute has become even more heated.


At this point, the issue is not about justifying rehabilitation or bankruptcy, but about making a decision on loss sharing. MBK, as the largest shareholder, can hardly avoid bearing a certain level of responsibility. Likewise, Meritz cannot escape public criticism by relying solely on the logic of creditor recovery. The Homeplus situation is not about who is more ethical, but about determining who will shoulder how much of the loss. If this question cannot be answered, even an additional two months will be unlikely to change the outcome.



Both sides need to put their calculations on the table and share the losses. This is the last possible way to save Homeplus, and also the only way to minimize criticism should bankruptcy become inevitable.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing