"Retrial Provisions Under the Act on the Expedited Trial of Criminal Cases Should Also Apply to Appellate Courts"

Even if a guilty verdict has been finalized in an in absentia trial conducted through public notification without the defendant's knowledge of the commencement of the proceedings, the Supreme Court has ruled that the defendant must be guaranteed the opportunity to request a retrial not only at the first instance but also at the appellate level.

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on July 2, the First Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Eom Sang-pil) overturned the previous court's decision to sentence Mr. A, who was indicted on fraud charges, to one year in prison, and remanded the case to the Suwon District Court.


Mr. A was brought to trial in February 2021 on charges of conspiring with members of a voice phishing organization, impersonating a financial institution employee, and fraudulently obtaining 7.1 million won from a victim under the pretense of loan repayment.


When the first instance court was unable to determine Mr. A's whereabouts, it sent a copy of the indictment and related documents via public notification, and proceeded with the trial in Mr. A's absence, ultimately sentencing him to one year in prison. Public notification refers to a method in which documents are posted on the court bulletin board and are deemed to have been delivered.


Subsequently, the prosecutor appealed the sentence as being unduly lenient, and the appellate court also sent a summons and other documents through public notification, conducting the proceedings without Mr. A present. Although the appellate court found there were procedural violations in the first court’s decision to use public notification, it nevertheless reviewed the case and again sentenced Mr. A to one year in prison.


Upon belatedly learning of the verdict, Mr. A filed an appeal through a procedure to restore his right to appeal. The key issue in this trial was whether the right to request a retrial, recognized under the Act on the Expedited Trial of Criminal Cases for defendants who were unable to attend court due to reasons beyond their control, could be analogously applied to the appellate stage, not just the first instance.


The Supreme Court determined that the legal principle of requesting a retrial under the special provisions of the Act on the Expedited Trial of Criminal Cases applies not only to the first instance but also analogously to the appellate court. This means that if a defendant, through no fault of their own, was unable to attend both the first and appellate trials and a guilty verdict was finalized, they have the right to request a retrial at the appellate court as well.



The court stated, "If the defendant was unable to attend the trial proceedings for reasons beyond their control, they may request a retrial within 14 days from the date they became aware of the verdict," adding, "Even if only the prosecutor appeals and the appellate trial is conducted in absentia, the defendant may request a retrial at the appellate court."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing