Some Frontline Prosecutors Call for Change
Concerns Raised Over Increased Vulnerability for Victims

As the government has decided to abolish the supplementary investigation authority of prosecutors at the soon-to-be-established Public Prosecution Office in three months, some within the prosecution are now arguing that prosecutors should be granted a third type of disposition power besides indictment or non-indictment. They claim that, without the supplementary investigation authority, it would be difficult for prosecutors to take responsibility for the final disposition of a case, so prosecutors should be allowed to refuse to handle cases where investigations are deemed insufficient. However, there are counterarguments that introducing a new type of disposition would not have a significant practical effect, such as resolving long-standing unresolved cases.


After Prime Minister Kim Minseok announced on June 25 that the government would move to abolish the supplementary investigation authority, Ahn Mihyun, a prosecutor at the Cheonan Branch of Daejeon District Prosecutors’ Office (Judicial Research and Training Institute, 41st class), argued, "If the supplementary investigation request by a Public Prosecution Office prosecutor is not properly carried out, prosecutors should be permitted to issue a 'cannot determine' decision regarding indictment." Prosecutor Ahn added, "Rather than repeatedly requesting supplementary investigations, this would be more effective in preventing cases from being indefinitely delayed."


Prosecutor Ahn explained that a 'cannot determine' decision is not about neglecting to process a case, but about encouraging investigative agencies to promptly comply with requests for supplementary investigation. She noted that such a decision could serve as a means of oversight for prosecutors, as investigative officers who receive a 'cannot determine' decision could be subject to inspection and thus face disadvantages in personnel matters.


Prosecutor Gong Bongsook (32nd class) from the Seoul High Prosecutors’ Office also argued that a new category, 'unable to determine (supplementation impossible or request for supplementation not fulfilled),' should be introduced. If a prosecutor issues a non-indictment decision on the grounds of insufficient evidence, it could have an adverse effect on victims involved in ongoing civil litigation, such as damage lawsuits.


There is a general sentiment among frontline prosecutors in favor of introducing a disposition that would allow them to refuse to process a case. One junior prosecutor said, "After the adjustment of investigative authority between prosecutors and police, prosecutors have become less willing to take responsibility as their powers have been reduced. If their authority is further diminished, there should at least be a 'return' disposition that allows them to refuse a case." Some prosecutors are concerned that, immediately after the launch of the Public Prosecution Office, the inability to issue any disposition could lead to a sharp increase in unresolved cases.


However, there are concerns that victims would be left in a vulnerable position. Kwon Naegeon (35th class), an attorney at Trinity Law Firm, said, "If a 'cannot determine' decision is issued, prosecutors would not need to provide detailed reasons for non-indictment, making it very difficult for the parties involved to accept." Attorney Kwon also pointed out, "It is not always possible to impose disadvantages on investigators simply because an investigation is insufficient. Sometimes, even if the investigation is lacking, the police's findings may still match the actual facts of the case."


The police side argues there is a problem with the fact that most supplementary investigation requests are made in a 'decision' format for which the prosecution bears little responsibility. According to the Prosecution Case Handling Rules, a supplementary investigation request in the form of a decision involves returning the entire case record to the police (Article 29, Paragraph 1, Subparagraph 1), which the police claim is, in effect, already a case refusal. The police insist that the 'additional request (Subparagraph 2)' method should become the basic principle.


Park Yongcheol, a professor at Sogang University Law School, stated, "While I understand the rationale for introducing a 'cannot determine' decision, it is unclear whether it would be effective in resolving long-term unresolved cases. The difference from the current supplementary investigation request is also unclear." Kim Hyekyung, a professor in the Department of Police Administration at Keimyung University, said, "Rather than that, it is more important to make supplementary investigation requests more specific and to allow prosecutors to 'manage' the progress of investigations after the request, thereby improving the quality of cooperation."



Reporter Park Seongdong, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing