[Reporter’s Notebook] Supplementary Investigation Authority That Cleared False Accusations... Abolition Would Undermine the Judicial Safety Net View original image

"A case was forwarded as a prostitution incident, but it turned out to be a rape involving threats with a weapon."


This case, introduced by Jang Junho, Chief Prosecutor at the Gangneung Branch of the Chuncheon District Prosecutors' Office, at the Criminal Justice Forum held on June 25, illustrates the necessity of the prosecution's supplementary investigative powers. Initially, the police forwarded a 16-year-old female student as a suspect on prostitution charges, citing a lack of additional evidence besides the victim's statement.


However, when the prosecution conducted a direct search and secured the vehicle's black box and a record of the mobile phone search history, the true nature of the case was revealed. Chief Prosecutor Jang asserted, "Without the power of supplementary investigation, it would have been difficult to uncover the truth."


The abolition of the prosecution’s supplementary investigation authority, which impacts the lives of the public, is now imminent. The expectation in the legal community that President Lee Jaemyung would allow for exceptions to the supplementary investigation authority has also been withdrawn. Former Prime Minister Kim Minseok stated, "After considering various opinions, the government has finalized the abolition of the supplementary investigation authority as its basic policy." The discussion on amending the Criminal Procedure Act is expected to accelerate rapidly.


However, on the ground, there are urgent voices calling for a reconsideration of abolishing the system. This is due to concerns that the side effects and resulting harm will be transferred directly to the public. There is also anxiety that inadequate investigations could conceal the truth and eliminate the means to correct unfair non-indictments that grant de facto immunity to criminals. Cases that require sufficient investigation to secure convictions may end up neglected.


The legal community largely agrees that the 'right to request supplementary investigation,' which some present as a compromise, is also insufficient. When the police miss decisive evidence or have a different opinion than the prosecutor, merely making a request is not enough to uncover the truth. Granting prosecutors the means to directly supplement evidence is not an issue of authority, but a matter of ensuring basic rights for the people.


An even greater concern is that the ability for external oversight of police misconduct will be rendered powerless. Until now, prosecutors have identified signs of police misconduct—such as lenient, targeted, or solicited investigations—during their review of forwarded case records. However, if the power of supplementary investigation is abolished, oversight of such abuses of power will have to rely solely on internal police controls.


The Seoul High Court Criminal Division 15-2 (Presiding Judge Lee Heejoon) recently dismissed the appeal of a police officer who was sentenced to six years in prison for accepting a bribe worth hundreds of millions of won in exchange for quashing a case. This incident occurred just a few months after the adjustment of investigative powers. The messages uncovered by the prosecution’s investigation included shocking content, such as, "Give me the money today. I'll make sure everything is not indicted."


Would these problems have come to light without the supplementary investigation authority? The aforementioned female victim might have suffered for life, stigmatized by a scarlet letter.



The essence of criminal justice system reform is not about dividing authority between agencies or political calculations, but about protecting the people. We must not commit the folly of undermining the safety net of the judicial system meant to rescue the vulnerable. Abolishing the system without a clear alternative to fill the judicial vacuum is not reform but regression.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing