Controversy Over Two Riders and Lack of Helmets Despite Good Deed
"Admirable" vs. "Dangerous" — Mixed Reactions Online

A video of a male student transporting an elderly person with mobility difficulties on an electric scooter to the entrance of a hospital emergency room has become a hot topic online. While many praised the act as a good deed for helping an elderly person who appeared to be in distress, there has also been debate regarding the issues of riding with two people on an electric scooter and not wearing a helmet.


On July 1, various social networking services (SNS) featured posts titled “Viral Video of a Minor on a Scooter.” The video shows a young man, presumed to be a student, arriving at the entrance of a hospital emergency room with an elderly person seated behind him on an electric scooter.

A young man, presumed to be a teenager, is seen giving a mobility-impaired elderly person a ride on an electric scooter to the emergency room. Screenshot from social media.

A young man, presumed to be a teenager, is seen giving a mobility-impaired elderly person a ride on an electric scooter to the emergency room. Screenshot from social media.

View original image

The location is known to be a regional emergency medical facility in Jeonju, North Jeolla Province. In the video, the student carefully parked the scooter in front of the emergency room, then helped the elderly person maintain balance and get off. After alighting, the elderly person, limping, headed into the emergency room, while the student bowed to the elderly person before leaving the scene.


Most viewers who watched the video responded warmly to the student’s actions. Comments included, “It’s admirable that he helped an elderly person in an emergency,” “At that age, that may have been the best option,” and “It’s impressive how carefully he assisted the elderly person until the end.” Some also said, “Regardless of whether regulations were violated, the act of kindness itself should be praised,” defending the student.


On the other hand, there were also many voices of concern. As electric scooters are designed as personal mobility devices intended for a single rider, some pointed out that carrying an elderly person as a passenger could have resulted in a more serious accident if they had fallen or collided with another vehicle during the ride. Comments included, “It turned out to be a heartwarming story because nothing happened, but it was actually very dangerous,” “If this is presented as a good deed, teenagers might imitate it,” and “If it was an emergency, calling 119 would have been safer.”

The student in the video carefully parked the kickboard in front of the emergency room, then helped the elderly person maintain balance and get off. Screenshot from SNS

The student in the video carefully parked the kickboard in front of the emergency room, then helped the elderly person maintain balance and get off. Screenshot from SNS

View original image

The controversy grew because it is also connected to current legal regulations. According to the Enforcement Rules of the Road Traffic Act, only one person is allowed on electric scooters and electric two-wheeled vehicles. If the driver of an electric scooter exceeds this limit by carrying a passenger, they may be subject to a fine. Both the driver and the passenger are required to wear protective gear such as helmets, but in the video, it is unclear whether helmets were worn, leading to further safety concerns.


However, some argue that criticism should be cautious, considering the elderly person’s condition and the surrounding circumstances at the time. The video alone does not show how the student ended up giving the elderly person a ride, whether calling 119 or seeking help from bystanders was possible, or how far the hospital was. There is also a view that actual legal consequences may vary depending on specific circumstances, such as the urgency at the time, availability of alternative means, and whether an accident occurred.



The ongoing occurrence of personal mobility device accidents has also fueled this controversy. According to the Korea Road Traffic Authority’s Traffic Accident Analysis System, there were 2,389 traffic accidents related to personal mobility devices in 2023, with 24 fatalities and 2,622 injuries. In particular, electric scooters have been repeatedly criticized for their small size and lack of protective features for riders, making them vulnerable to falls, collisions, and accidents involving pedestrians.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing