Interview with Isil Erel, Professor of Finance at Ohio State University, USA.
"Board Independence Cannot Be Achieved by Legal Amendments Alone"

"Renaming outside directors to independent directors would not be enough if those directors are ultimately chosen because of their personal ties or legacy relationships with the CEO, nominating committees, or controlling shareholders. By generating an unbiased, data-driven candidate shortlist, not from the insiders’ social circles, AI can help reach better director independence."


Isil Erel, Professor of Finance at Ohio State University, USA. Asian Finance Association (AsianFA)

Isil Erel, Professor of Finance at Ohio State University, USA. Asian Finance Association (AsianFA)

View original image

Isil Erel, David A. Rismiller Chair in Finance at Ohio State University, USA, recently shared her thoughts on strengthening the independence of outside directors in an interview with The Asia Business Daily. Professor Erel, who has researched director selection using machine learning and cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&A), is scheduled to deliver a keynote speech at the Asian Finance Association (AsianFA) international conference to be held at Seoul National University from August 2 to 4.


Professor Erel called for a fundamental change in the way board members are selected in order to strengthen board independence. She said, "I highly appreciate recent efforts by the (Korean) government, such as amendments to the Commercial Act, but they are not sufficient to enhance the independence of outside directors," adding, "This is because board members can still be appointed due to close ties with management or controlling shareholders." The amended Commercial Act includes provisions to prevent outside directors from acting as mere rubber stamps by adding shareholders as beneficiaries of fiduciary duty and by changing the title to 'independent director.'


Specifically, she proposed an AI-based director selection method. Professor Erel explained, "When making director appointments, human decision-makers tend to overvalue factors such as male candidates, personal connections with management, and participation on multiple boards," and added, "In contrast, AI removes these network-driven biases and focuses strictly on data-driven predictions with the sole objective of maximizing shareholder value."


This approach was also detailed in Professor Erel's 2021 paper, "Director Selection via Machine Learning." AI, after training on data from newly appointed outside directors of U.S. listed companies from 2000 to 2011, accurately predicted outcomes such as shareholder approval rates for outside directors from 2012 to 2014.


However, to date, no listed company has adopted a machine learning-based approach. Professor Erel explained, "A director holds both fiduciary duty and legal responsibility to shareholders, but AI cannot be held accountable," adding, "Board members' fear of losing control is another reason why AI-driven director selection has not been embraced."


The solution Professor Erel suggests is to use AI as a supplement. She emphasized, "The most realistic approach is for AI to narrow down a pool of potential candidates to three to five people, after which the nomination committee selects the most suitable individual as a director," and added, "The very act of identifying candidates outside of internal networks is the first step toward ensuring board independence."


Regarding structural reforms in the stock market, such as amendments to the Commercial Act that the Korean government has pursued since last year, she assessed them as "excellent progress." However, she also pointed out that the completion of reform lies in a strong enforcement mechanism. Professor Erel stated, "No matter how good a law may be, it is useless if companies or major shareholders do not comply. In order for the law to actually function and eliminate the 'Korea discount,' a robust judicial system—such as class action lawsuits—must be in place so that minority shareholders can hold the board and major shareholders accountable."


Additionally, Professor Erel expressed concern that the unique ownership structures of major Korean conglomerates remain a hurdle to checks by foreign investors. She remarked, "No matter how much equity foreign or institutional investors acquire, chaebols still maintain firm control through cross-shareholding among affiliates," and pointed out, "This closed structure creates a technically challenging environment for outside shareholders to voice calls for governance reform."


She also warned of the risks of private credit. Professor Erel analyzed, "The scale of private credit has surpassed 2 trillion dollars worldwide and is expanding rapidly in Asia as well. When you account for stock and bond yields and subtract general partner (GP) fees, we found that investor returns approach zero." She further cautioned, "Investors must beware of the illusion of diversification and avoid having unrealistic expectations that do not match the actual risks."



Meanwhile, at the 2026 AsianFA annual conference, where Professor Erel will deliver the keynote address, the latest financial research achievements by scholars worldwide will be presented. In addition to sessions for the presentation of approximately 200 academic papers, separate panel sessions will be held on key capital market issues and supervisory work. The event is jointly organized by the Korea Finance Association and the College of Business Administration at Seoul National University.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing