Image Replaced After AI Watermark Is Found
Explanations Also Contradicted by Game Footage

Paichai High School, which sparked controversy by chanting a regionally disparaging slogan during a baseball game against Gwangju Jeil High School, has issued an apology, but criticism continues to mount. The controversy has intensified because traces of Google’s generative artificial intelligence (AI) were found in the apology image, and the school’s claim that “some students were immediately stopped” is being contradicted by video footage of the game.

On the 29th, during the Cheongryong Nationwide High School Baseball Championship match between Paichai High School and Gwangju Jeil High School, Paichai High School players were cheering, shouting the slogan "Let's go to Starbucks." Captured from an online community.

On the 29th, during the Cheongryong Nationwide High School Baseball Championship match between Paichai High School and Gwangju Jeil High School, Paichai High School players were cheering, shouting the slogan "Let's go to Starbucks." Captured from an online community.

View original image

According to the education community and other sources on June 30, Paichai High School posted an apology statement on its official website and social media the previous day, stating, “The inappropriate cheering slogan by some student athletes caused deep hurt and disappointment to the Gwangju Jeil High School team, parents, alumni, Gwangju citizens, and many others.”

Gemini Watermark Remains in Apology… Questions Over Sincerity

The school explained that the students who chanted the problematic slogan were immediately stopped on site and that an apology was conveyed to the Gwangju Jeil High School baseball team after the game. The school also stated that the students involved would be referred to the Student Life Education Committee and that special training on sportsmanship, human rights sensitivity, and athlete ethics would be provided to all baseball team members.

Apology statement regarding the controversy over the cheering slogan released by Paichai High School. A generative AI ‘Gemini’ watermark is displayed at the bottom right. Paichai High School

Apology statement regarding the controversy over the cheering slogan released by Paichai High School. A generative AI ‘Gemini’ watermark is displayed at the bottom right. Paichai High School

View original image

However, as the apology statement was uploaded in image format, a watermark indicating that Google’s generative AI “Gemini” had been used to create the image was discovered at the bottom right, raising doubts about the sincerity of the apology. Online commenters criticized, saying, “Did they even leave the official apology to AI?” and, “This is an insincere apology.” The image was later replaced with a version where the watermark was no longer visible.

Video Shows Multiple Players Participating… Contradicts “Immediate Restraint” Explanation

There were also claims that the school was downplaying the situation. Broadcast footage from the game showed several players in the dugout swaying and repeatedly chanting, “Let’s go, let’s go, let’s go to Starbucks.” The situation only subsided after the Gwangju Jeil High School coaching staff protested and the umpires gave a warning, which differs from the school’s explanation that “only some students” were involved and that there was “immediate restraint.”


This controversy arose during the 81st Cheongryonggi National High School Baseball Championship and Weekend League King of Kings match between Paichai High School and Gwangju Jeil High School, held at Mokdong Baseball Stadium in Seoul on June 29. In the top of the eighth inning, with Paichai High School leading, some players chanted “Let’s go to Starbucks” toward the opposing dugout, and it was also reported that the phrase “Tank Day” was mentioned at the scene.


The slogan has been interpreted as a reference to last month’s so-called “5·18 Tank Day” event controversy involving Starbucks Korea. Gwangju Jeil High School immediately protested to the umpires, who then issued a warning to the Paichai High School team.


Gwangju Jeil High School baseball head coach Cho Yoonchae stated after the game, “The opposing team engaged in taunting that was difficult to understand,” and added, “It was something that could hurt our students.” Paichai High School head coach Kwon Oyung responded, “The students did wrong. The responsibility lies greatly with the adults who failed to properly educate them,” and offered an apology to Gwangju Jeil High School.



The Seoul Metropolitan Office of Education plans to visit Paichai High School to examine the circumstances under which the slogan was chanted, whether there was on-site intervention, how the student athletes are being guided, and the school’s follow-up measures and education plans to prevent recurrence. The Korea Baseball Softball Association also intends to conduct its own investigation and review by the Sports Fairness Committee to consider the team’s management responsibilities and any disciplinary action.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing