Fragmentation of Investigative Authority Accelerates with Police-Prosecution Reform and Launch of Special Prosecution

Defense Strategies Evolve... "Focus Shifts to Challenging Procedural Flaws First"

Court rulings to dismiss indictments, including the case of former Supreme Court Justice Kwon Soon-il for violation of the Attorney-at-Law Act, have been occurring in succession. Analysts suggest that as investigative authority becomes more fragmented and jurisdictional boundaries are further delineated, the importance of procedural and formal requirements in investigations is increasing.

Courts Strictly Adhering to Investigation Procedures and Authority... Dismissal of Indictments Becoming More Frequent View original image

According to legal professionals on June 30, the Seoul Central District Court Criminal Division 21 Single Judge Bench (Presiding Judge Kim Daegyu) dismissed the indictment against former Justice Kwon for violation of the Attorney-at-Law Act on June 11. The court ruled that the crime of violating the Attorney-at-Law Act does not fall within the scope of direct investigation by prosecutors as defined by Article 4 of the Public Prosecutors' Office Act. The court also rejected prosecutors' claims that direct investigation was permissible based on its relation to crimes over which they had authority to initiate investigations. The ruling found it unlawful for the prosecution to have resumed the investigation after receiving the case from the police, as the police had not yet exercised their primary authority to conclude the investigation.


A dismissal of indictment is a formal decision to end a trial before reaching a substantive verdict on the defendant's guilt or innocence, based on defects in jurisdiction or procedural requirements. Article 327 (2) of the Criminal Procedure Act stipulates that a dismissal shall be issued "when the procedure for prosecution violates the provisions of the law and is therefore invalid." This includes: ▲ prosecution by an agency without investigative authority, ▲ abuse of prosecutorial power, and ▲ indictments based on unlawful investigations.


Judges in trial courts analyze the recent increase in dismissals as a consequence of institutional changes such as the 2021 adjustment of investigative authority between the police and prosecution, which is now manifesting at the trial stage. As investigative powers are fragmented and the boundaries of authority for each investigative agency become clearer, the courts' procedural scrutiny is also becoming stricter. Another factor is changes in defense strategy by defendants and their counsel. A judge from the Seoul High Court explained, "In the past, arguments mainly focused on guilt or innocence, but now, defendants and defense attorneys are challenging every procedural flaw from the outset. As a result, dismissals and other procedural judgments have become more prominent."


The Supreme Court has also ruled on so-called "parallel investigations"—cases outside the scope of a special prosecutor's mandate. On June 24, the Supreme Court's Third Division (Presiding Justice Lee Sukyeon) upheld the lower court's dismissal of an indictment for bribery against a Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport official, Mr. Kim, in an appellate review. The special prosecutor investigating the Yangpyeong Expressway route change allegations indicted Mr. Kim for accepting bribes in his personal capacity. However, the Supreme Court found no reasonable connection between the route change allegations and Mr. Kim's personal corruption, ruling this a case of unlawful parallel investigation.


The same legal principle was applied in the special prosecutor's case regarding insurrection. On June 22, the Seoul Central District Court Criminal Division 33 (Presiding Judge Lee Jinkwan) rendered a verdict in the insurrection case against former Justice Minister Park Seongjae, while also dismissing the indictment for perjury before the National Assembly against former Legislation Minister Lee Wankyu. The court held that Mr. Lee's alleged false testimony before the National Assembly did not fall within the investigative scope stipulated by the Special Prosecutor Act on insurrection.


As dismissals of indictments continue, investigative agencies themselves appear to be changing their practices. A Seoul High Court judge noted, "In the past, prosecutors from the Gangneung branch would sometimes ignore jurisdiction and bring suspects from Incheon for drug cases. Recently, investigative agencies are paying much more attention to jurisdiction and procedural matters than before."


Regarding concerns raised in some quarters about investigative gaps resulting from dismissals, some argue that the defendant's fundamental rights must take priority. The issue can be resolved if investigative agencies clearly define their jurisdiction from the initial stages of an investigation. A judge from the Seoul Central District Court stated, "There is no other body but the court to control cases where an indictment is brought after an investigation by an agency without jurisdiction. The court is ensuring defendants' rights not to be investigated by an agency lacking investigative authority."



This trend is expected to influence the criminal justice system as a whole ahead of the implementation of the Prosecution Office Act and the Central Investigation Agency Act in October. This is because investigative powers will be newly divided among the police, the Central Investigation Agency, and the Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials. The legal community broadly agrees that disputes over jurisdiction and cases subject to judicial review are bound to increase structurally, leading to a corresponding rise in dismissal rulings. A Seoul High Court judge said, "Since legislative changes have newly fragmented and defined the scope of authority for each investigative agency, the trend of indictments being dismissed is likely to increase for some time." A Seoul Central District Court judge added, "As investigative authority is divided, the courts are in the process of setting new standards."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing