Shinhan and Korea Investment Holdings Face Off in Two-Way Race for Lotte Insurance

Financial Group Aiming to Scale Up Insurance vs Securities Group Targeting Managed Assets

KRW 1 Trillion Price Tag Emerges as Key Variable

The acquisition battle for Lotte Insurance, cited as the largest target among non-life insurers, has become a two-way race as Shinhan Financial Group, a financial holding company, and Korea Investment Holdings, a securities holding company, have both entered the competition. Since Shinhan Financial Group aims to grow the insurance business as a core part of its profit portfolio, while Korea Investment Holdings seeks to leverage the insurer's assets under management for returns, the outcome is expected to bring significant changes to the insurance market landscape.


Securities Holding vs. Financial Holding: A Two-Way Race for Lotte Insurance Acquisition View original image

According to the insurance industry on June 30, Shinhan Financial Group has reportedly begun private negotiations with JKL Partners, the private equity fund (PEF) manager and largest shareholder of Lotte Insurance. Shinhan Financial Group has formed a dedicated task force for the acquisition of Lotte Insurance and is currently preparing for due diligence.


Korea Investment Holdings also disclosed on June 29 that it is considering the acquisition of Lotte Insurance. Since last year, Korea Investment Holdings has established a task force dedicated to insurance company acquisitions and has been reviewing various potential targets from multiple angles. Industry analysts point out that, as seen in the case of Meritz Fire & Marine Insurance, if the focus is placed on the profitability of managed assets and capital efficiency rather than insurance operations, a life insurer with a larger asset base may be more suitable than a non-life insurer.


For this reason, there is significant interest in why Korea Investment Holdings has decided to participate in the bid for Lotte Insurance, a non-life insurer. Korea Investment Holdings states that it is not exclusively targeting Lotte Insurance, but is instead broadly reviewing all available insurance companies on the market to enter the insurance sector. Submitting a letter of intent to acquire is part of the standard process, which includes selection as a preferred bidder and due diligence. The final decision on whether to proceed with the acquisition will be made after a comprehensive assessment of the due diligence results and the price.


In the case of Shinhan Financial Group, the main objective of the acquisition is to strengthen its relatively weak insurance portfolio compared to its other affiliates. While its subsidiaries in banking, securities, credit cards, life insurance, and capital are all market leaders in their respective sectors, its non-life insurance unit ranks at the very bottom of the industry. In fact, Shinhan EZ Insurance has assets of just KRW 347.4 billion, which is the lowest level in the industry. This contrasts with Shinhan Life, which ranks fourth in the life insurance sector. However, if the group acquires Lotte Insurance, which has assets of KRW 14 trillion, it could instantly rise to seventh place among non-life insurers.


Kookmin Financial Group (KB Financial Group), the top player in the industry, has also expanded its non-banking profits through its insurance subsidiary, and this is cited as one of the reasons Shinhan Financial Group has entered the fray. For KB Financial Group, KB Insurance ranks third in terms of contribution to total revenue, following banking and securities, among its 11 subsidiaries.


An official from a major commercial bank stated, "After KB Financial Group acquired LIG Insurance (now KB Insurance), the performance contribution from non-banking businesses increased significantly. While financial companies are broadly reviewing all insurance companies available on the market, Lotte Insurance is currently attracting the most attention."


The key issue is price. The price tag for Lotte Insurance demanded by JKL Partners is reportedly around KRW 1 trillion. Shinhan Financial Group also believes this price is excessive. Korea Investment Holdings likewise considers a 'reasonable price' as the number one criterion for any acquisition. A representative from Korea Investment Holdings commented, "None of the previous M&A deals were concluded at expensive prices. The first and second conditions for acquisition are both the price."


Given the differing strategies that financial holding companies and securities holding companies have for insurance companies, the future direction of Lotte Insurance's management and business strategy is expected to change depending on who becomes the new owner.



An industry official commented, "While financial holding companies tend to focus on developing insurance as a new profit pillar, securities holding companies aim to utilize an insurer's long-term assets under management to bolster their wealth management (WM) and investment banking (IB) competitiveness. Even for the same acquisition, the post-acquisition business strategy and synergies will differ depending on the buyer."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing