With JTBC's declaration of default and the successive applications for corporate rehabilitation by five key affiliates, including its holding company Jungang Holdings, judicial risks facing the owner family—such as Vice Chairman Hong Jungdo at the top of the governance structure and Contentree Jungang CEO Hong Jungin—are coming to the fore. There is a prevailing sentiment that the owner family will find it difficult to avoid responsibility, given their deep involvement in corporate management as representatives and executives. In particular, suspicions have been raised that the owner family unfairly supported certain affiliates to strengthen their control within the group and to pursue private interests, thereby weakening other affiliates. This is intensifying the possibility of investigations into charges of breach of trust and violations of the Fair Trade Act.


Hong Jungdo, Vice Chairman of Jungang Group, is moving after completing the corporate rehabilitation petition representative examination held at the Seoul Bankruptcy Court. Photo by Yonhap News.

Hong Jungdo, Vice Chairman of Jungang Group, is moving after completing the corporate rehabilitation petition representative examination held at the Seoul Bankruptcy Court. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image

‘Round-Robin’ Guarantees and Potential Breach of Trust


The total borrowings of Jungang Group amount to approximately 3 trillion won. As of the end of last year, Jungang Holdings' total liabilities stood at about 1.503 trillion won, with total equity at around 32.9 billion won, resulting in a debt ratio of 4,564.7%. JTBC’s debt ratio is 2,443.6%, while Contentree Jungang’s is 1,020.9%. Notably, JTBC has been in a state of capital erosion since 2016.


Amid chronic deficits, Jungang Group’s temporary solution was ‘debt roll-over’ among affiliates. The amount entangled in mutual payment guarantees and credit extensions among affiliates alone exceeds 225 billion won. With most assets financed by debt, when one affiliate faltered, the payment guarantees served as a trigger, causing the entire group to stagger simultaneously.


Legal experts point out that providing payment guarantees to insolvent affiliates without appropriate compensation or collateral can be subject to review for breach of trust related to business practices. For breach of trust to be established, intent and the pursuit of illegal gain at the time must be considered. However, if it is determined that the decision-makers could have reasonably foreseen the financial condition and potential losses of the supported companies but still proceeded, thereby causing substantial damage to the corporation, legal liability may arise. Vice Chairman Hong Jungdo served as CEO of JoongAng Ilbo JTBC from 2014 to 2022.


JTBC Takes the Risk, SLL Jungang Reaps the Gains


Within the broadcasting industry, the peculiar business structure between JTBC and SLL Jungang, an affiliate responsible for production and distribution, is being pointed to as the reason why JTBC accumulated deficits despite producing hits such as "SKY Castle," "The World of the Married," "Itaewon Class," and "Reborn Rich." This is because Jungang Group separated JTBC’s content production function and funneled its core intellectual property (IP) business to SLL Jungang. JTBC bore the production costs, while SLL Jungang reaped the profits, creating a structure where JTBC could not share in the gains.


JTBC holds only a 2.84% stake in SLL Jungang. Vice Chairman Hong Jungdo owns 4.00%, and President Hong Jungin holds 1.18%. The largest shareholder of SLL Jungang is Contentree Jungang, with a 53.82% stake, and Vice Chairman Hong also owns 1.17% of Contentree Jungang. This structure means Vice Chairman Hong has a direct stake in SLL Jungang and an indirect interest through the upper-tier company. Notably, President Hong Jungin became co-CEO of Contentree Jungang in 2022 and has also served as an internal director at SLL Jungang, subsequently leading SLL Jungang’s management. Thus, the owner family is not only a shareholder in SLL Jungang, which is identified as a beneficiary entity, but also has directly participated in management as a board member.


As a result, JTBC bears the costs and risks associated with content production, while the profits and corporate value from successful IP business are concentrated in SLL Jungang. Some allege that the restructuring of the content business was orchestrated to enhance the corporate value of SLL Jungang, which is closely tied to the interests of Vice Chairman Hong and Contentree Jungang. An antitrust lawyer, speaking on condition of anonymity, stated, "If it is found that quality assets were transferred to a specific affiliate, thereby distorting market order, it could be considered unfair support."


Potential Owner Violations of the Capital Markets Act Also at Issue


Whether fraudulent unfair trading under the Capital Markets Act has been committed is also a key issue. JTBC declared default after failing to repay 20.6 billion won in securitized loans. The problem is that the relevant corporate bonds and short-term electronic bonds were heavily issued in August last year and February this year, precisely when the company’s liquidity crisis was accelerating.


Legal experts note that if it is revealed that there were already serious issues with the company’s ability to repay debt at the time of issuance, and these were not adequately disclosed while bonds were sold to investors, it could constitute fraudulent unfair trading under the Capital Markets Act. They further point out that even if one is not the CEO but an owner exercising substantial influence over the company, they may still be held legally responsible if they directed such bond issuance.


There is also speculation that the Financial Supervisory Service may launch a formal investigation. Financial authorities plan to first review the appropriateness of the overall issuance process of commercial papers and corporate bonds, and, if signs of wrongdoing are found, may escalate to a formal investigation and refer the case to law enforcement agencies.



Reporter Woobin, Legal Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing