Index Still Below Its Level at Launch 30 Years Ago

Inflated Estimated Earnings Before IPO Deepen Distrust in Stock Prices

Penalties Needed, Such as Extending Mandatory Holding Periods, When Performance Gaps Are Large

The KOSPI index, although experiencing some stagnation, is moving toward the 10,000 mark. In contrast, the KOSDAQ index, which will turn 30 next month, remains below 1,000. This is even lower than the level at its inception in 1996. Due to its lack of maturity relative to its age, a flood of ideas for KOSDAQ reform has emerged since last year, ranging from 'independence of the KOSDAQ Market Division' to a 'three-division league promotion and relegation system.' However, concerns about potential side effects are being raised from various quarters even before any of these proposals are implemented.

[The Editors' Verdict] Let's Fix KOSDAQ's 'Inflated Stock Prices' as It Turns Thirty View original image
[The Editors' Verdict] Let's Fix KOSDAQ's 'Inflated Stock Prices' as It Turns Thirty View original image

There is broad consensus that the core problem of KOSDAQ is 'investor distrust.' Issues regarding governance, such as the abuse of power by the largest shareholders, certainly exist. However, the more fundamental issue lies in price—namely, stock prices that do not correspond with the actual fundamentals of the companies.


In microeconomics, price is the optimal point where supply meets demand. Companies going public (IPO) must seek out this optimal point as early as the public offering price determination stage. Typically, for profitable companies, the valuation is based on a three-year period—one year before and after the IPO—while for loss-making companies, estimates are based on expected earnings for the next three years. At a minimum, the future value for one to three years must be projected.


Since these are essentially 'estimates,' the income statement, which connects revenue, operating profit, and net profit, inevitably contains numerous 'assumptions (If~).' A significant degree of subjective judgment from the company is involved. This means that even the most basic financial statements can easily be inflated.


In particular, earnings estimates for technology-based companies granted special listing status despite operating at a loss are virtually a 'black box.' This is because the company exclusively controls key information such as the probability of technological success or global competitiveness. Companies preparing for listing exploit this 'information asymmetry' to inflate their projected earnings as much as possible.


Venture capitalists (VCs), who are investors, and underwriters (securities firms), who assist with the listing, also have aligned interests in 'inflating public offering prices.' VCs want a high initial share price to sell their shares at a premium, while underwriters collect higher fees when the total public offering amount is larger.


The Korea Exchange, well aware of these circumstances, is encouraging higher discount rates on estimated prices during the preliminary review process for listings, thereby lowering public offering prices. However, complex earnings adjustments in the income statement remain the responsibility of the company and the underwriter.


Ordinary investors who participate after the listing primarily refer to the income statement. Therefore, to restore trust in KOSDAQ, the projected earnings disclosed in the securities registration statement at the time of the public offering must be as close as possible to the actual earnings reported in the quarterly business reports after listing. In response, financial authorities have made it mandatory to disclose the deviation rate between projected and actual earnings.


However, simply resorting to 'naming and shaming' by highlighting large deviation rates is not enough. For example, explicit post-listing measures should be stipulated, such as designating companies as 'under supervision' if, after three years, actual earnings fall below 50% of projections; extending mandatory shareholding periods for the largest shareholders and related parties; and imposing punitive fines on underwriters.


Only by holding those who led the listing process strictly accountable can the temptation to inflate offering prices be eliminated. This will help establish reasonable share prices from the outset of the listing. Over time, the entrenched information asymmetry in KOSDAQ will be alleviated.



Jo Siyoung, Head of the Securities and Capital Markets Department


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing