Samil PwC Governance Focus: "Board Guide"

"Korean Companies Need to Expand Boards and Increase Outside Directors with Expertise" View original image


There are growing concerns that the size and expertise of boards of directors at domestic companies are lacking compared to major global corporations. Calls are being made to expand the boards and increase the number of outside directors with management expertise.


On June 29, the Samil PwC Governance Center announced the publication of the 36th issue of its "Governance Focus" series, which addresses these concerns based on a contribution by Professor Myung-Hyun Cho from Korea University's Business School.


According to the article, as of last year, the average board size of companies included in the U.S. S&P 500 Index was about 10.7 members, with approximately 9.2 being outside directors. In contrast, listed domestic companies with total assets of 2 trillion won or more had an average board size of only 7.5 members, including 4.5 outside directors. Professor Cho stated, "There is no single correct answer for the optimal board size, but Korean companies need to expand their boards." He emphasized, "Considering the increasingly complex business environment, boards should be strengthened by securing outside directors with diverse business expertise."


Currently, while the number of committees—such as audit committees, internal transactions committees, compensation committees, and ESG committees—is increasing at domestic companies, the number of board members has stagnated, leading to structural limitations. In some cases, a single director is serving on as many as four or five committees, or is participating in committees unrelated to their area of expertise.


Professor Cho suggested, "Each committee requires different expertise, so when one director serves on multiple committees, it becomes difficult to perform in-depth roles in each area." He advised, "Companies should expand the size of their boards in accordance with their specific characteristics and reallocate personnel based on the expertise needed for each committee."


"Korean Companies Need to Expand Boards and Increase Outside Directors with Expertise" View original image

The debate over increasing the proportion of outside directors was also covered. Supporters argue that the proportion of outside directors should be increased to enhance independence and enable decision-making based on collective intelligence. Opponents point out that, unlike in the United States, the proportion of outside directors with C-level experience on domestic boards is low, and that boards are often composed mainly of former government officials, professors, and legal experts, who may lack sufficient business understanding.


Professor Cho emphasized that, "Rather than adjusting proportions by reducing internal directors, the preferred alternative is to expand the overall board size and reinforce it with outside directors who have business and management expertise." He also presented the key principles for effective board composition as ▲independence, ▲expertise, and ▲diversity.


As a way to systematically manage board capabilities, he suggested utilizing a "Board Skills Matrix (BSM)." The BSM is a tool that systematically organizes the board competencies required for company strategy and is used to assess the appropriateness of board composition. It is applied in investor communications and the appointment process for new directors, and is spreading as a global best practice. Among U.S. S&P 500 companies, the proportion including a BSM in their proxy statements increased significantly from 38% in 2020 to 73% in 2024. However, use among domestic companies remains limited.


Meanwhile, the full text of this article can be found on the Samil PwC Governance Center website. Samil PwC plans to publish a comprehensive guidebook at the end of the year, compiling its monthly board guide series.



Wanggun Shin, head of the Samil PwC Governance Center, stressed, "We must move beyond simply expanding the size of boards and achieve substantive governance reform through strategic board composition based on the BSM." He added, "In particular, it is urgent to develop a pool of outside director candidates with management and industry expertise."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing