[Why&Next] Lotte Card Sanctions Decision Delayed to July... M&A Impact Hinges on Level of Penalty
Focus on Possible Reduction of 4.5-Month Suspension
'Aggravated Sanctions' Still Possible Despite Lotte Card's Defense
Further Decline Below KRW 2 Trillion Valuation Could Impact M&A Prospects
The financial authorities’ decision regarding business restrictions on Lotte Card has been delayed for over two weeks, heightening industry interest in the severity of the sanctions. The outcome is expected to impact not only Lotte Card’s fundamentals but also future merger and acquisition (M&A) strategies that could reshape the landscape of the card industry.
Decision Expected After Mid-July... Focus on Business Suspension Level
According to the financial sector on June 29, the Financial Services Commission decided at its agenda subcommittee on June 25 to revisit the sanctions plan related to the Lotte Card hacking incident at a later date. The final result is expected to be announced after mid-July. Currently, following a review by the Financial Supervisory Service’s Sanctions Deliberation Committee, a proposal for a 4.5-month business suspension and a 5 billion won fine has been passed on to the Commission as a severe penalty.
The longer the duration of the business suspension, the more Lotte Card will inevitably suffer setbacks in attracting new customers and achieving credit sales performance. For Lotte Card, which recently sought a rebound by slightly increasing its membership from 9,556,000 last year to 9,566,000 this year, these sanctions could be a detrimental factor that undermines its recovery momentum.
At a Crossroads Over 'Aggravated Sanctions'... CEO Sangho Jung Explains Consumer Protection Efforts
The key issue for the Financial Services Commission’s agenda subcommittee is whether to treat this incident as a “repeat violation” following the 2014 information leak and to apply aggravated sanctions. According to the Enforcement Decree of the Specialized Credit Finance Business Act, the Commission can adjust the level of sanctions by up to 50%, considering the degree and frequency of violations.
Initially, most industry observers predicted that the authorities would impose a harsher penalty than the previous three-month business suspension, given that the current administration has significantly strengthened supervision of internal controls and customer information leaks at financial companies.
A senior industry official commented, “Despite efforts by card companies to improve their internal control systems since the 2014 information leak, another hacking incident occurred, so there is some validity to the argument that Lotte Card should bear heavier responsibility than in the past. It remains to be seen what decision the authorities will make.”
In response, Lotte Card CEO Sangho Jung attended the agenda subcommittee in person to explain the company’s consumer protection measures implemented after the incident. At the meeting, CEO Jung reportedly outlined plans to establish a Financial Consumer Protection Committee within the board of directors, composed of four members including the CEO; to increase the information security budget to 15% of the IT budget; and to invest a total of 120 billion won in information security over the next five years.
Lotte Card is emphasizing that the recent hacking incident was caused by “external hacker intrusion,” not by illegal acts or intentional data leaks by internal employees. The company also points out that there is no precedent for imposing a business suspension on a financial institution due to damages from hacking, which forms a key part of its defense.
An industry official stated, “Since there is no precedent for business suspension over hacking damages at financial institutions, the Financial Services Commission appears to be deliberating carefully over the appropriate level of sanctions against Lotte Card, holding multiple agenda subcommittee meetings.”
Decline in Corporate Value... Long-term Impact on M&A Prospects
The severity of the sanctions is directly linked to Lotte Card’s corporate value. Once valued at 3 trillion won, Lotte Card’s worth has now fallen to around 2 trillion won. Some analysts predict that if severe sanctions are finalized, the valuation could drop to the 1 trillion won range.
The current major shareholder, private equity firm MBK Partners, has been tight-lipped regarding a potential sale. To make matters worse, the company is under investigation by the Fair Trade Commission for alleged unfair internal transactions related to Homeplus Card, making it difficult to push ahead with the sale of Lotte Card at this time.
The market is increasingly adopting a wait-and-see approach, anticipating that Lotte Card’s corporate value may drop further after the sanctions. In this climate, potential acquirers such as Hana Card and Woori Card, which are part of major financial holding groups, are reportedly less motivated than before.
In the case of Woori Card, it was considered a strong candidate because its group’s key affiliate, Woori Bank, owns a 20% stake in Lotte Card. However, recently, Lim Jongryong, Chairman of Woori Financial Group, shifted the group’s strategy toward strengthening its non-interest portfolio by seeking to acquire Dongyang Life and ABL Life instead of Lotte Card, moving toward divesting its stake.
Hana Card is still mentioned as a strong potential acquirer. However, it is expected that Hana Card will likely adjust its pace and wait for the sanctions level and related changes in corporate value, only proceeding if the acquisition price becomes sufficiently attractive.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An industry official said, “Considering the potential synergy with existing customers and the level of internal controls, if the price is right, there will certainly be financial companies interested in acquiring Lotte Card. The level of sanctions imposed by the authorities will be a key variable determining the sale price and timing.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.