Entered One-Tenth of the Intended Price of 3,170,000 Won

Court: "Cannot Cancel... Buyer Could Not Have Known of the Mistake"

A seller who mistakenly listed billiards equipment for 317,000 won instead of the intended 3,170,000 won and later requested to cancel the transaction lost the lawsuit. The court ruled that the buyer had not been informed of the seller’s intended price, and therefore the error was not sufficient grounds to cancel the contract.


AI-generated image to assist in understanding the article. ChatGPT

AI-generated image to assist in understanding the article. ChatGPT

View original image

According to Yonhap News on June 26, Judge Noh Minsik of the Seoul Central District Court (35th Civil Division) recently ruled against the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by seller A against buyer B, in which A demanded delivery of the goods and other claims.


In March of last year, A posted an advertisement on a secondhand trading platform offering to sell expensive billiards equipment as a set, listing the price as 317,000 won. After seeing the post, B expressed the intention to purchase all of the items, and payment and delivery were completed within a day.


The issue arose only after the transaction was completed. A realized the pricing mistake only after receiving payment. The intended sale price was 3,170,000 won, but due to an error, it was listed at one-tenth of that amount, 317,000 won.


A argued that there had been a significant mistake regarding an essential part of the contract and requested that B cancel the transaction and return the goods. Civil law stipulates that a declaration of intent may be revoked if there is a mistake concerning an essential element of a legal act.


B proposed either paying A compensation of 500,000 won or selling the purchased goods back to A. However, negotiations between the two parties broke down, and the dispute proceeded to litigation.


The court found that A’s pricing error did not constitute a “material mistake” that would permit cancellation of the contract. The reasoning was that B would have had no way of knowing that A originally intended to sell the items for 3,170,000 won.


Following Supreme Court precedent, the court considered A's mistake to be merely an “error in motive,” not a material legal mistake.



The court stated, “To revoke a declaration of intent on the grounds of a mistaken motive, the motive must have been communicated to the other party and recognized as part of the contract. Based on the evidence presented, it is difficult to conclude that B was informed of the intended sale price of 3,170,000 won.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing