Court: "Less Than 2 Square Meters Per Inmate Is Unlawful"
Claim Dismissed Due to Lack of Evidence of Overcrowding

Twenty-four inmates filed a lawsuit demanding 39.5 million won from the state, claiming they suffered psychological distress due to excessively cramped correctional facilities, but their case was dismissed. The court acknowledged that if the per-inmate space falls below 2 square meters, it could be unlawful, but determined there was insufficient evidence that the plaintiffs were actually subjected to overcrowding.


Incheon District Court

Incheon District Court

View original image

According to Yonhap News on June 26, Kim Yangho, the presiding judge of Civil Division 28 at the Incheon District Court, dismissed a lawsuit in which 24 correctional facility inmates, including individual A, sought approximately 39.5 million won in damages from the Republic of Korea. The court also ruled that the plaintiffs must bear the litigation costs.


The plaintiffs claimed that during their confinement, they were unable to secure even the minimum space required for basic living, which caused them psychological distress.


The court stated that while some of the inmates' basic rights may be restricted during their time in correctional facilities, such restrictions must not infringe upon their dignity and value as human beings.


The court further noted that unless there are special circumstances, such as a temporary surge in the number of inmates making short-term overcrowding unavoidable, overcrowding itself could undermine the inmates' dignity.


Regarding the specific legal standard, Judge Kim explained, "If the floor area per inmate is less than 2 square meters, it exceeds the tolerable limit and is therefore unlawful."


However, in this case, the court concluded that there was insufficient evidence to admit that the plaintiffs were actually subjected to overcrowding beyond this standard.



Judge Kim stated, "Even considering all the evidence, including the findings from inquiries to each prison warden, it is not sufficient to recognize the plaintiffs' claims that they were held in conditions exceeding the tolerable limit," explaining the reason for dismissing the claim.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing