Building Constructed with 94 Square Meters Encroaching on Another’s Land
Lower Courts: “20 Years of Occupation, Ownership Recognized”
Supreme Court: “Not a Mistake... Acquisitive Prescription Not Allowed”

The Supreme Court has ruled that one cannot claim ownership of a building constructed on another person's land simply because 20 years have passed. If the area of encroachment exceeds what could be considered a typical construction error, the court found that it should be regarded as willful and unauthorized occupation, with the trespasser fully aware that the land belonged to someone else. In such cases, the statute of limitations for acquisition by adverse possession cannot be recognized.

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to legal sources on June 29, the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Shin Sookhee) overturned the previous rulings that had sided with building owner B in a lawsuit filed by landowner A seeking the return of unjust enrichment, as well as in a counterclaim by B for the registration of ownership transfer. The Supreme Court sent the case back to the lower court for retrial.


In 1993, B purchased a plot of land (76 square meters) in Paju and constructed a building on it. Later, when the owner of the neighboring plot (106 square meters) passed away and his son, A, inherited the land, it was discovered that B's building had been constructed encroaching on as much as 94 square meters of A's land, rather than solely on B's own property.


A then filed a lawsuit demanding the return of unjust enrichment, equivalent to the overdue rent, while B counter-sued, arguing, "I have occupied the land peacefully and openly for 20 years, so under the Civil Act, it is now mine." B based this claim on the principle of acquisition by adverse possession, which allows for the acquisition of ownership if one occupies real estate peacefully and openly with the intention of ownership for 20 years.


The first and second trials accepted B’s argument. The courts presumed that B had occupied the land under the belief that it was his own since 1993, concluded that the period of adverse possession was fulfilled, and ruled that A should transfer ownership of the land to B.


However, the Supreme Court overturned the previous decisions, finding that B must have known from the outset that the building was being constructed on someone else’s land. According to Supreme Court precedents, if the extent of encroachment by a building on another’s land is substantial and goes beyond what could be considered a typical construction error, it must be assumed that the builder was aware of the encroachment. In such cases, the "intention of ownership" (adverse possession) is negated, and the statute of limitations for acquisition by adverse possession cannot be recognized.



The court stated, "The area (94 square meters) encroached by B's building goes beyond a typical construction error," adding, "Furthermore, even in the process of losing ownership of the adjacent land through an auction in 1999, B acknowledged that the building was on someone else’s land, so the intention of ownership cannot be recognized." This was given as the reason for overturning and remanding the case.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing