Criminal Justice Forum Explores "The Direction of Criminal Justice in an Era of Great Change"

With just three months left until the enforcement of the Prosecution Service Act and the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency Act in October, members of the legal and academic communities gathered to discuss issues such as investigative gaps caused by the separation of investigation and prosecution, as well as overlapping jurisdictions between agencies.

Joonho Jang, Head of the Gangneung Branch of Chuncheon District Prosecutors' Office, is delivering the keynote speech at the 11th Criminal Justice Forum held on the 25th at the EL Tower in Seocho-gu, Seoul, under the theme "Direction of Criminal Justice in the Era of Great Change." Photo by Taewon Choi

Joonho Jang, Head of the Gangneung Branch of Chuncheon District Prosecutors' Office, is delivering the keynote speech at the 11th Criminal Justice Forum held on the 25th at the EL Tower in Seocho-gu, Seoul, under the theme "Direction of Criminal Justice in the Era of Great Change." Photo by Taewon Choi

View original image

The Legal Research and Training Institute and the Korea Institute of Criminology and Justice Policy co-hosted the 11th Criminal Justice Forum on the 25th at the EL Tower in Seocho-gu, Seoul, under the theme "Direction of Criminal Justice in the Era of Great Change."


Joonho Jang, Head of the Gangneung Branch of Chuncheon District Prosecutors' Office, delivered a keynote presentation that pointed out problems of overlapping jurisdiction and evasion of responsibility resulting from a proliferation of investigative agencies, and proposed alternatives. He suggested granting primary and exclusive jurisdiction to specific investigative agencies in certain areas, but exceptionally allowing continued investigative authority to other agencies such as the police if they have initiated compulsory measures like search and seizure. In addition, he emphasized the need to swiftly conclude inter-agency memoranda of understanding (MOUs) through practical consultative bodies, in order to clarify the transfer of cases and the scope of investigations, and to ultimately enshrine these measures in legislation.


He also made it clear that the right to request supplementary investigations alone is insufficient. Jang stated, "If the effectiveness of supplementary investigation requests can be assured, a substantial portion of issues can be addressed, but it remains difficult to uncover all the facts if the police have fatally missed evidence or if there are significant differences in opinion between the police and prosecutors." He cited a case in which the prosecution, after the police referred a prostitution case, uncovered through direct supplementary investigation that it was actually an armed rape case against a 16-year-old female student, ultimately leading to the suspect's detention. He explained, "It is difficult to expect such substantive fact-finding based solely on the prosecutor's requests for supplementary investigation after reviewing records."


Kyungkyu Park, Head of the Criminal Law Research Division at the Korea Institute of Criminology and Justice Policy, also pointed out that the current Serious Crimes Investigation Agency Act merely lists offenses without defining or setting criteria for serious crimes, making overlapping and conflicting jurisdiction with other investigative agencies inevitable. He further stated, "It is functionally impossible to completely separate the act of deciding whether to investigate and prosecute," and argued that cooperation between prosecutors and police during the investigation phase must be significantly strengthened in order to prevent issues arising from inadequate police investigations.


During the subsequent discussion, both support for the reform and practical concerns were voiced. Sangkyu Han, Professor at Ajou University Law School, described the reform as a "constitutional and procedural decision aimed at controlling the excessive expansion of state prosecutorial power." He argued that the proliferation of investigative agencies should be seen not as inefficiency, but as a "process of mature checks and balances."


Sanghee Han, Professor at Konkuk University Law School, characterized the current situation as a "prosecutor's republic" where legal and political power are merged, and underscored the need for reform. He stated that the separation of investigation and prosecution should be pursued from the perspective of "reducing state power and enabling political power to self-regulate," and diagnosed the situation as a "process of a major paradigm shift."


Sanghoon Han, Professor at Yonsei University Law School, said that the separation of investigation and prosecution should be accepted as a "demand of the times." He explained that when prosecutors hold both the authority to request warrants and to prosecute, and also conduct direct investigations, it could result in confirmation bias and politically targeted investigations. However, he also proposed a compromise: even if prosecutors do not have compulsory investigative powers, they should at least be granted minimal discretionary investigative authority to decide on prosecution.



On the other hand, Hodong Cha, attorney at Lee & Ko, argued that "active and proactive judicial oversight by prosecutors must be maintained to prevent human rights violations that cannot be remedied solely through ex post judicial review." Changon Lee, Professor at Ewha Womans University Law School, warned that "if investigative agencies with investigative tools are separated from prosecution agencies that have final decision-making responsibility, this could structurally encourage the shifting of responsibility and procedural delays." Hongseok Yang, attorney at Lee Gong Law Firm, also pointed out that it may be administratively impossible to screen the hundreds of thousands of police notifications received annually.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing